Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team

Butternut Box vs HEY HOLY

Butternut Box logo

Butternut Box

No. 7 of 138 in dog food brands9.1

Best for: Fresh-cooked dog meals on a flexible UK subscription, with treats added on the same account.

HEY HOLY logo

HEY HOLY

No. 55 of 138 in dog food brands9.2

Best for: Adult dog owners in Germany, Austria, Switzerland and France who want a personalised, vet-formulated subscription.

See the category

Key differences

  • HEY HOLY scores higher overall: 9.2 against 9.1.
  • Among support channels, only Butternut Box offers Phone.
  • Among support channels, only HEY HOLY offers Email.
  • HEY HOLY is available in 3 more countries.
  • Among food types, only HEY HOLY offers Dry and Wet.

Side by side

Butternut Box vs HEY HOLY
Butternut Box logoButternut BoxHEY HOLY logoHEY HOLY
Cost
Price from£1.76€3.90
Price per day£1.76above the median of 8 brandsNot listed
Offer
SpeciesDogDog
Food typesFresh cooked, TreatsDry, Wet, Treats, Fresh cooked
Personalised recipeYesYes
Introductory discount50%Higherin the highest quarter of 106 brands30%above the median of 106 brands
Recipes12above the median of 104 brandsNot listed
ProteinsBeef, Chicken, Turkey, Salmon, Lamb, Pork
+ 3 moreDuck, Fish, Venison
Lamb, Trout, Horse, Duck
Grain-free optionYesYes
Life stagesAllAdult
Human-grade claimYesNo
Trust
Nutrition standardComplete fediafComplete fediaf
Formulated byVet nutritionistVet nutritionist
MarketsUnited KingdomGermany, Austria, Switzerland, France
Delivery and service
Delivery modelSubscriptionSubscription
Pause or cancel onlineYesYes
Frozen shippingYesNo
Company
Legal entityNot listedHEY HOLY GmbH
HeadquartersNot listedGermany
Founded2016Not listed
Support channelsChat, Phone, Help centreEmail, Chat, Help centre

Our verdict on each

Butternut Box

Butternut Box suits UK dog owners who want fresh-cooked meals and treats delivered on a subscription with portions matched to their dog. Entry pricing starts at £1.76, and the intro offer of 50% takes the first boxes well down. Treats come from the same kitchen rather than a separate line.

Read the full Butternut Box review

HEY HOLY

HEY HOLY suits adult dog owners in Germany, AT and CH who want a personalised subscription spanning dry, wet and treats rather than a fixed shelf. Entry starts at €3.90, the intro offer takes 30% off the first order, and renewal runs at the standard price with pause and cancel run online.

Read the full HEY HOLY review

If neither fits

How they place

Fresh dog food delivery
Butternut Box 3 of 34 by score · HEY HOLY 15 of 34 by score
Dog treats
Butternut Box 10 of 145 by score · HEY HOLY 52 of 145 by score

Pros and cons

Butternut Box

Pros

  • Portions are personalised, and pause and cancel both run online.
  • Recipes are formulated by a vet nutritionist and meet complete fediaf standards.
  • Fresh-cooked meals and treats both ship frozen, so the whole box arrives cold.

Cons

  • Delivery is subscription only, so there is no single box to try before committing.
  • Coverage is limited to GB, so buyers outside the UK get no delivery.
  • Food types run to fresh cooked and treats, so there is no dry or wet format to switch to.

HEY HOLY

Pros

  • Personalised feeding is offered, and pause and cancel can be handled online.
  • Formulated by a vet nutritionist, with a complete FEDIAF nutrition standard.
  • Food types cover dry, wet and treats, so one plan can span treats and fresh-cooked meals.

Cons

  • Life stages are listed as adult only, so the range does not cover puppies or senior dogs.
  • Human grade claim is listed as no, so buyers who want food described as suitable for people should look elsewhere.
  • Support runs on email, chat and help centre, and a phone line is not among the listed channels.

Who each suits

Butternut Box

Who it suits

  • UK dog owners feeding fresh-cooked meals who want portions matched to their dog
  • Households that want meals and treats from one subscription
  • Anyone who prefers frozen delivery over shop-bought ambient food

Who should look elsewhere

  • Buyers outside GB, where there is no delivery
  • People wanting dry or wet food, which Ollie and tails.com both list
  • Shoppers who want a one-off box instead of subscription, since PetPlate carries a wider format range

HEY HOLY

Who it suits

  • Owners who want recipes matched to their dog rather than a fixed range
  • Feeders who need dry, wet, treats and fresh-cooked in one subscription

Who should look elsewhere

  • Puppy and senior households, since life stages cover adult only
  • Anyone who needs to reach support by phone, since support runs on email, chat and help centre

Questions about each

Butternut Box

How much does Butternut Box cost per day?

The plan starts at £1.76, which works out at £1.76 a day for a fed dog. Portions are personalised, so the day rate follows your dog’s size rather than the box. That daily figure is the recurring cost to plan around.

Is there a discount for new customers?

Yes. New customers get 50% off the opening order, and the brand places 4 of 103 tracked brands on entry offers. The saving applies at the start, and the ongoing rate returns to the standard plan price after the intro period.

HEY HOLY

How much does HEY HOLY cost at entry and at renewal?

Entry starts at €3.90, and the first order carries an intro offer of 30%. Delivery is a subscription, so the figure that matters for the rest of the plan is the standard rate that follows the opening order rather than the headline entry price. Pause and cancel are handled online if the recurring rate does not suit.

What does the introductory discount apply to?

The intro offer is listed at 30%, which places HEY HOLY at 30 of 103 brands ranked on opening discounts, above the dog food median introductory offer of 20%. It applies to the opening order, after which the standard subscription price takes over, so it is worth setting a reminder before the next delivery.