Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team

Butternut Box vs Only Natural Pet

Butternut Box logo

Butternut Box

9.1

Best for: Fresh-cooked dog meals on a flexible UK subscription, with treats added on the same account.

Only Natural Pet logo

Only Natural Pet

9.1

Best for: US owners feeding adult dogs and cats on air-dried, dry, freeze-dried, wet food and treats.

See the category

Key differences

  • Among support channels, only Only Natural Pet offers Email.
  • Among species, only Only Natural Pet offers Cat.
  • Among food types, only Butternut Box offers Fresh cooked.
  • Among food types, only Only Natural Pet offers Air dried, Dry and Freeze dried.
  • Among proteins, only Butternut Box offers Turkey, Salmon and Lamb.

Side by side

Butternut Box vs Only Natural Pet
Butternut Box logoButternut BoxOnly Natural Pet logoOnly Natural Pet
Cost
Price from£1.76$32.99
Price per day£1.76above the median of 8 brandsNot listed
Offer
SpeciesDogDog, Cat
Food typesFresh cooked, TreatsAir dried, Dry, Freeze dried, Wet, Treats
Personalised recipeYesNo
Introductory discount50%Higherin the highest quarter of 106 brands35%above the median of 106 brands
Recipes12Higherabove the median of 104 brands2in the lowest quarter of 104 brands
ProteinsBeef, Chicken, Turkey, Salmon, Lamb, Pork
+ 3 moreDuck, Fish, Venison
Chicken, Beef
Grain-free optionYesYes
Life stagesAllAdult
Human-grade claimYesYes
Trust
Nutrition standardComplete fediafComplete AAFCO
Formulated byVet nutritionistVet nutritionist
Delivery and service
Delivery modelSubscriptionOne off
Pause or cancel onlineYesYes
Frozen shippingYesNo
Company
Legal entityNot listedONP-EComm, LLC
HeadquartersNot listedUnited States
Founded20162002
Support channelsChat, Phone, Help centreEmail, Chat, Phone, Help centre
Other facts
Energy per 100 gNot listed340 kcalsbelow the median of 81 brands
ProteinNot listed34%in the highest quarter of 113 brands
FatNot listed16%above the median of 111 brands
MarketsUnited KingdomUnited States

Part scores

Butternut Box

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.1
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.4
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more8.5

Only Natural Pet

  • CostThe price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read more9.0
  • OfferWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read more9.2
  • TrustCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more9.0

Our verdict on each

Butternut Box

Butternut Box suits UK dog owners who want fresh-cooked meals and treats delivered on a subscription with portions matched to their dog. Entry pricing starts at £1.76, and the intro offer of 50% takes the first boxes well down. Treats come from the same kitchen rather than a separate line.

Read the full Butternut Box review

Only Natural Pet

Only Natural Pet is a US natural-style food store for owners of adult dogs and cats who want air-dried, dry, freeze-dried, wet food and treats on a set schedule. It scores 9.1 overall, with the auto delivery saving at 15% to 35% and food starting at $32.99.

Read the full Only Natural Pet review

Pros and cons

Butternut Box

Pros

  • Portions are personalised, and pause and cancel both run online.
  • Recipes are formulated by a vet nutritionist and meet complete fediaf standards.
  • Fresh-cooked meals and treats both ship frozen, so the whole box arrives cold.

Cons

  • Delivery is subscription only, so there is no single box to try before committing.
  • Coverage is limited to GB, so buyers outside the UK get no delivery.
  • Food types run to fresh cooked and treats, so there is no dry or wet format to switch to.

Only Natural Pet

Pros

  • A vet service is available, which most of the stores in the online pet stores ranking do not offer.
  • Recipes are formulated by a vet nutritionist and the range carries a human grade claim.
  • Auto delivery can be paused and cancelled online, and a loyalty scheme is in place.

Cons

  • There is no pharmacy, so medicines have to come from a pharmacy counter elsewhere.
  • Same day delivery is not offered, so nothing arrives the day the order is placed.
  • The range is not personalised, with diets set by recipe rather than by individual pet.

Who each suits

Butternut Box

Who it suits

  • UK dog owners feeding fresh-cooked meals who want portions matched to their dog
  • Households that want meals and treats from one subscription
  • Anyone who prefers frozen delivery over shop-bought ambient food

Who should look elsewhere

  • Buyers outside GB, where there is no delivery
  • People wanting dry or wet food, which Ollie and tails.com both list
  • Shoppers who want a one-off box instead of subscription, since PetPlate carries a wider format range

Only Natural Pet

Who it suits

  • US owners of adult dogs and cats who want a single store for air-dried, dry, freeze-dried, wet food and treats
  • Shoppers who already plan to set up auto delivery and want 15% to 35% off repeat orders
  • Owners who want a vet service in the same place as the food order

Who should look elsewhere

  • Anyone needing a pharmacy counter, since there is none here, and PETstock covers a wider supply basket for the same kind of basket order
  • US shoppers wanting same day delivery, which Petbarn handles through its own store network instead
  • Owners looking for personalised diets, which PetSmart Canada’s in store team can discuss at length

Questions about each

Butternut Box

How much does Butternut Box cost per day?

The plan starts at £1.76, which works out at £1.76 a day for a fed dog. Portions are personalised, so the day rate follows your dog’s size rather than the box. That daily figure is the recurring cost to plan around.

Is there a discount for new customers?

Yes. New customers get 50% off the opening order, and the brand places 4 of 103 tracked brands on entry offers. The saving applies at the start, and the ongoing rate returns to the standard plan price after the intro period.

Only Natural Pet

How much does Only Natural Pet food cost?

The entry price is $32.99 for the cheapest item in the range. That is the starting figure rather than a typical basket, and the cost per day depends on the recipe and the size of the dog. Buying on the auto delivery schedule instead takes 15% to 35% off each order.

Is there free delivery on orders?

Free delivery starts at $49. Below that basket size, a flat $5.95 shipping fee is charged, so a single small order costs that fee on top of the product price. A monthly scheduled order usually clears the threshold and drops the fee altogether.

Sources

Butternut Box

  • butternutbox.com: 19 facts, checked 30 September 2026

Only Natural Pet

  • onlynaturalpet.com: 23 facts, checked 30 September 2026