Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Butternut Box vs Redbarn Pet Products
Butternut Box
No. 7 of 138 in dog food brands9.1Best for: Fresh-cooked dog meals on a flexible UK subscription, with treats added on the same account.

Redbarn Pet Products
No. 8 of 138 in dog food brands9.1Best for: A single US brand covering dog and cat food plus treats, delivered on a subscription you can pause online.
Key differences
- Among support channels, only Redbarn Pet Products offers Email.
- Among species, only Redbarn Pet Products offers Cat.
- Among food types, only Butternut Box offers Fresh cooked.
- Among food types, only Redbarn Pet Products offers Air dried, Dry and Wet.
- Among proteins, only Butternut Box offers Chicken, Turkey and Salmon.
Side by side
Redbarn Pet Products | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Price from | £1.76 | $7.92 |
| Price per day | £1.76above the median of 8 brands | Not listed |
| Offer | ||
| Species | Dog | Dog, Cat |
| Food types | Fresh cooked, Treats | Air dried, Dry, Wet, Treats |
| Personalised recipe | Yes | No |
| Introductory discount | 50%in the highest quarter of 106 brands | Not listed |
| Recipes | 12above the median of 104 brands | 39Higherin the highest quarter of 104 brands |
| Proteins | Beef, Chicken, Turkey, Salmon, Lamb, Pork+ 3 moreDuck, Fish, Venison | Beef, Lamb, Pork |
| Grain-free option | Yes | Yes |
| Life stages | All | Puppy, Adult, Senior, All |
| Human-grade claim | Yes | No |
| Trust | ||
| Nutrition standard | Complete fediaf | Complete AAFCO |
| Formulated by | Vet nutritionist | Not stated |
| Delivery and service | ||
| Delivery model | Subscription | Subscription |
| Pause or cancel online | Yes | Yes |
| Frozen shipping | Yes | No |
| Company | ||
| Headquarters | Not listed | United States |
| Founded | 2016 | 1996 |
| Support channels | Chat, Phone, Help centre | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre |
| Other facts | ||
| Energy per 100 g | Not listed | 349.4 kcalsbelow the median of 81 brands |
| Protein | Not listed | 24%at the median of 113 brands |
| Fat | Not listed | 14%above the median of 111 brands |
| Markets | United Kingdom | United States |
Part scores
Butternut Box
Our verdict on each
Butternut Box
Butternut Box suits UK dog owners who want fresh-cooked meals and treats delivered on a subscription with portions matched to their dog. Entry pricing starts at £1.76, and the intro offer of 50% takes the first boxes well down. Treats come from the same kitchen rather than a separate line.
Read the full Butternut Box reviewRedbarn Pet Products
Redbarn Pet Products suits US dog and cat owners who want air-dried, dry and wet food alongside treats on a subscription they can pause online. The dog food is labelled to complete AAFCO, and the brand holds a trust score of 9.4 on a market of US.
Read the full Redbarn Pet Products reviewIf neither fits
How they place
- Dog treats
- Butternut Box 10 of 145 by score · Redbarn Pet Products 11 of 145 by score
Pros and cons
Butternut Box
Pros
- Portions are personalised, and pause and cancel both run online.
- Recipes are formulated by a vet nutritionist and meet complete fediaf standards.
- Fresh-cooked meals and treats both ship frozen, so the whole box arrives cold.
Cons
- Delivery is subscription only, so there is no single box to try before committing.
- Coverage is limited to GB, so buyers outside the UK get no delivery.
- Food types run to fresh cooked and treats, so there is no dry or wet format to switch to.
Redbarn Pet Products
Pros
- Covers air-dried, dry, wet and treats in one place, so dog and cat households can order meals and chews from a single account rather than juggling two suppliers
- A grain free option is available, which suits dogs that do not settle well on grain and gives owners a route without leaving the range
- Pause and cancel are handled online, so a delivery can be held or stopped without a call, a message or a retention conversation
Cons
- There is no human grade claim on the range, so owners who shop on that wording will need to look at a brand that makes it
- Personalised feeding is not offered, so recipes are not matched to a specific dog and portion plans stay the same across dogs of a size
- The market is US, so UK and EU households face import cost or need a domestic seller instead
Who each suits
Butternut Box
Who it suits
- UK dog owners feeding fresh-cooked meals who want portions matched to their dog
- Households that want meals and treats from one subscription
- Anyone who prefers frozen delivery over shop-bought ambient food
Who should look elsewhere
- Buyers outside GB, where there is no delivery
- People wanting dry or wet food, which Ollie and tails.com both list
- Shoppers who want a one-off box instead of subscription, since PetPlate carries a wider format range
Redbarn Pet Products
Who it suits
- US households feeding both a dog and a cat who want one order and one account rather than two separate brands
- Owners who want air-dried treats and chews sitting in the same order as everyday dry and wet meals
- Anyone who wants a subscription they can pause and cancel online without a phone call, and who is content with standard shelf-stable bags
Who should look elsewhere
- Owners who need every meal matched to a health condition, a breed profile or a bespoke ingredient list
- UK and EU buyers who need a domestic market, since Redbarn Pet Products runs in the United States and imports carry added cost
- People who rely on frozen or chilled delivery, or who want fresh-cooked and raw formats, since Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com each cover dog food and Redbarn covers air dried, dry and wet
Questions about each
Butternut Box
How much does Butternut Box cost per day?
The plan starts at £1.76, which works out at £1.76 a day for a fed dog. Portions are personalised, so the day rate follows your dog’s size rather than the box. That daily figure is the recurring cost to plan around.
Is there a discount for new customers?
Yes. New customers get 50% off the opening order, and the brand places 4 of 103 tracked brands on entry offers. The saving applies at the start, and the ongoing rate returns to the standard plan price after the intro period.
Redbarn Pet Products
How much does Redbarn Pet Products cost to start?
Entry pricing begins at $7.92, and the range is sold as a subscription rather than a single bag, so the figure worth comparing is the repeat delivery rather than the shelf ticket. The site cost score for this brand reads 8.9, and treats sit in the same order.
Can I pause or cancel the subscription?
Yes. Pause and cancel are both handled online, so there is no need to call or email in order to stop a delivery or hold a box until you have space for it. Support is listed across email, chat and phone if a question comes up first. Frozen shipping is not involved, so a paused order is not a chilled box sitting outside the door, and you can change plans without ending the relationship.
Sources
Butternut Box
- butternutbox.com: 19 facts, checked 30 September 2026
Redbarn Pet Products
- redbarn.com: 21 facts, checked 30 September 2026











