Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Salty Cat vs The Granville Island Pet Treatery
Salty Cat
No. 15 of 110 in cat food brands and delivery9.6Pick Salty Cat for the higher score (9.6 against 9.0).

The Granville Island Pet Treatery
No. 1 of 110 in cat food brands and delivery9.0Pick The Granville Island Pet Treatery for more markets (2 against 1).
Key differences
- Salty Cat scores higher overall: 9.6 against 9.0.
- Among support channels, only Salty Cat offers Help centre.
- The Granville Island Pet Treatery is available in 1 more country.
- Among species, only The Granville Island Pet Treatery offers Dog.
- Among food types, only Salty Cat offers Wet.
Side by side
The Granville Island Pet Treatery | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost and Offer | ||
| Price from | $1 | CA$9.90 |
| Species | Cat | Dog, Cat |
| Food types | Freeze dried, Wet, Treats | Freeze dried, Treats |
| Personalised recipe | Yes | No |
| Recipes | 24above the median of 104 brands | Not listed |
| Proteins | Beef, Chicken, Duck, Lamb, Minnow, Salmon+ 2 moreSardine, Tuna | Sardine, Pork, Beef, Salmon, Kangaroo, Cod+ 4 moreTuna, Goat, Chicken, Turkey |
| Grain-free option | Yes | Yes |
| Life stages | Adult | Not listed |
| Human-grade claim | Yes | Yes |
| Trust | ||
| Nutrition standard | Not listed | Complementary |
| Formulated by | Vet nutritionist | Not stated |
| Delivery and service | ||
| Delivery model | Subscription | One off |
| Frozen shipping | Not listed | No |
| Other facts | ||
| Protein | Not listed | 60.6%in the highest quarter of 113 brands |
| Fat | Not listed | 13.2%above the median of 111 brands |
| Markets | United States | Canada, United States |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Not listed | The Granville Island Pet Treatery Corp. |
| Headquarters | Not listed | Canada |
| Founded | Not listed | 1985 |
| Support channels | Email, Help centre | |
Our verdict on each
Salty Cat
Salty Cat suits US cat owners who want a personal plan rather than a fixed range. Plans start at $1 and a personal feeding profile sits behind 24 recipes, so it earns a place ahead of Bella + Duke, PETstock and Tackenberg for anyone chasing individual portions instead of a standard scoop.
Read the full Salty Cat reviewThe Granville Island Pet Treatery
The Granville Island Pet Treatery suits dog and cat owners who want freeze-dried extras without signing up for a plan, and an entry price of CAD 9.90 keeps a trial basket cheap. The nutrition standard is complementary, so it pairs with a main food rather than replacing one.
Read the full The Granville Island Pet Treatery reviewPros and cons
Salty Cat
Pros
- Personalised plans come as standard rather than as an upgrade, and 24 recipes give room to adjust within the range.
- Plans start at $1, and the cost score for the brand sits at 9.9.
- The food is formulated by a vet nutritionist, listed as vet nutritionist, which is the level of detail plenty of rival packs leave off.
Cons
- Adult only: adult lists adult, so kittens and senior cats sit outside the plan.
- Support runs on email and help centre, so there is no phone line for a shopper who prefers to talk a portion change through.
The Granville Island Pet Treatery
Pros
- Buying is one off, so nothing renews and there is no plan to cancel.
- A grain free option and a human grade claim, the details treat shoppers tend to look for first.
- A single catalogue covering dog and cat, where Salty Cat lists cat and stays with cats alone.
Cons
- The nutrition standard is complementary, so these are treats and toppers rather than a complete meal.
- Support runs on email, so a phone conversation is not part of the deal.
- Frozen shipping is not used, so a dog already fed raw keeps taking cold boxes from a seller that does use it.
Who each suits
Salty Cat
Who it suits
- US households with an adult cat that need portions set for that cat, and that would pay for it rather than pick a standard scoop from Bella + Duke.
- Cat owners who want wet, freeze-dried and treats from freeze dried, wet and treats on one plan, instead of buying a main food and treats from separate shops.
- Shoppers who treat a vet nutritionist sign-off (vet nutritionist) and a human grade claim as a quality filter when choosing a brand.
Who should look elsewhere
- Dog owners: cat is cat only, while Bella + Duke covers dog and cat and Tackenberg covers dog and cat for a mixed household.
- Anyone feeding kittens or senior cats: adult lists adult only, so a household feeding every stage should weigh a broader range such as PETstock or Tackenberg instead.
- Shoppers who want a phone line: support runs on email and help centre only, so a conversation-led buyer should compare Bella + Duke first.
The Granville Island Pet Treatery
Who it suits
- Dog and cat owners in Canada and the United States who want a treat or a freeze-dried extra bought as needed rather than on a plan.
- Pets that do not do well on grains, since a grain free option is available.
Who should look elsewhere
- Not for cat only shopping, because Salty Cat lists cat while this brand mixes dog and cat.
- Not for a raw feeding plan: Bella + Duke lists raw and treats, and this brand lists freeze dried and treats.
- Not for stocking a full food shop, because PETstock lists dry, wet and freeze dried under the same roof.
Questions about each
Salty Cat
How much does Salty Cat cost to start?
The lowest entry price in the range is $1, and the brand sits at position 11 of 152 brands ranked on that figure, so the headline number is not the cheapest on the site.
What happens to the price after the first order?
Salty Cat sells on a subscription model, so each box repeats on the same plan until you change or stop it. The price you start on is the one that keeps recurring, and introductory discounts in the wider cat food ranking sit at 15%, so it is worth reading the current offer before judging the ongoing rate.
The Granville Island Pet Treatery
What do treats from The Granville Island Pet Treatery cost?
The listed entry price is CAD 9.90, and buying is one off rather than a plan, so no renewal price sits behind it. The range covers freeze dried and treats for dog and cat. Across the brands compared here the median introductory discount is 20%, and this range does not lean on one because nothing repeats.
Is there a subscription or a renewal price?
No. Delivery is one off, so each order stands alone and you decide when the next bag is needed. Nothing recurs, and nothing has to be cancelled. That suits a household whose main food already arrives on its own schedule and only wants the treat cupboard topped up now and then.
Sources
Salty Cat
- saltycat.com: 13 facts, checked 30 September 2026
The Granville Island Pet Treatery
- pettreatery.com: 18 facts, checked 30 September 2026






