Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
PetSmart vs Salty Cat
Key differences
- Salty Cat scores higher overall: 9.6 against 9.4.
- Salty Cat has a lower entry price ($1 against $3.09).
- Among support channels, only PetSmart offers Phone.
- Among support channels, only Salty Cat offers Email.
- Among species, only PetSmart offers Dog.
Side by side
| Cost and Offer | ||
|---|---|---|
| Price from | $3.09 | $1Lower |
| Species | Dog, Cat | Cat |
| Food types | Dry, Wet, Fresh cooked, Raw | Freeze dried, Wet, Treats |
| Personalised recipe | No | Yes |
| Introductory discount | 40%in the highest quarter of 106 brands | Not listed |
| Recipes | 1,815Higherin the highest quarter of 104 brands | 24above the median of 104 brands |
| Proteins | Chicken, Salmon, Beef, Lamb, Turkey | Beef, Chicken, Duck, Lamb, Minnow, Salmon+ 2 moreSardine, Tuna |
| Grain-free option | Yes | Yes |
| Life stages | Puppy, Adult, Senior, All | Adult |
| Human-grade claim | No | Yes |
| Formulated by | Not stated | Vet nutritionist |
| Markets | United States | United States |
| Delivery and service | ||
| Delivery model | Retail | Subscription |
| Pause or cancel online | Yes | Not listed |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | PetSmart LLC | Not listed |
| Headquarters | United States | Not listed |
| Founded | 1987 | Not listed |
| Support channels | Phone, Help centre | Email, Help centre |
Our verdict on each
PetSmart
PetSmart suits US pet owners who want food, a pharmacy and vet care in one account rather than a single recipe box. Food starts at $3.09, the Auto Ship schedule carries the repeat discount, and personalised food is an outright no.
Read the full PetSmart reviewSalty Cat
Salty Cat suits US cat owners who want a personal plan rather than a fixed range. Plans start at $1 and a personal feeding profile sits behind 24 recipes, so it earns a place ahead of Bella + Duke, PETstock and Tackenberg for anyone chasing individual portions instead of a standard scoop.
Read the full Salty Cat reviewPros and cons
PetSmart
Pros
- Pharmacy and a vet service are both yes, so medication and check-ups are handled in the same account as the food order
- Same day is yes and dispatch runs 1 to 3 days, so a shop that runs short mid-week can still be covered
- The dog range holds 1,815 recipes across dry, wet and fresh cooked formats, and a grain free option is yes
Cons
- Personalised food is no, so a dog on an elimination or prescription diet is served by choosing a listed recipe rather than a made one.
- Shipping is limited to the US, so a basket placed from another country sits outside the $49 free delivery threshold.
- The salmon and rice dry recipe lists its formulator as not stated and the human grade claim is no, so the 1,815 recipes behind that shelf carry no named nutritionist or human grade wording to weigh.
Salty Cat
Pros
- Personalised plans come as standard rather than as an upgrade, and 24 recipes give room to adjust within the range.
- Plans start at $1, and the cost score for the brand sits at 9.9.
- The food is formulated by a vet nutritionist, listed as vet nutritionist, which is the level of detail plenty of rival packs leave off.
Cons
- Adult only: adult lists adult, so kittens and senior cats sit outside the plan.
- Support runs on email and help centre, so there is no phone line for a shopper who prefers to talk a portion change through.
Who each suits
PetSmart
Who it suits
- US households feeding more than one pet, since the range covers dog and cat from a single delivery
- Owners who want a pharmacy and a vet service handled in the same account as the food order
- Regular Auto Ship buyers who like a wide shelf, with 1,815 dog recipes to pick a repeat order from
Who should look elsewhere
- PetSmart Canada, if the basket ships to Canada, since its free delivery threshold of CAD 49 is priced for that market
- PETstock, if the basket is small or Australian, since its free delivery threshold of AUD 25 is lighter than the $49 asked here
Salty Cat
Who it suits
- US households with an adult cat that need portions set for that cat, and that would pay for it rather than pick a standard scoop from Bella + Duke.
- Cat owners who want wet, freeze-dried and treats from freeze dried, wet and treats on one plan, instead of buying a main food and treats from separate shops.
- Shoppers who treat a vet nutritionist sign-off (vet nutritionist) and a human grade claim as a quality filter when choosing a brand.
Who should look elsewhere
- Dog owners: cat is cat only, while Bella + Duke covers dog and cat and Tackenberg covers dog and cat for a mixed household.
- Anyone feeding kittens or senior cats: adult lists adult only, so a household feeding every stage should weigh a broader range such as PETstock or Tackenberg instead.
- Shoppers who want a phone line: support runs on email and help centre only, so a conversation-led buyer should compare Bella + Duke first.
Questions about each
PetSmart
How much does PetSmart food cost to get started?
Dog food on the site starts at $3.09. Prices are set per product, so that figure is a single entry point rather than a typical monthly basket. A loyalty scheme is in place for repeat orders, and returns run 60 days, so a small first bag carries little risk.
Does the Auto Ship discount last, or is the headline discount only for joining?
Two rates sit side by side. Joining Auto Ship is advertised at 40%, while the ongoing schedule takes 5% to 35% off repeat orders. The sign-up saving is the larger of the two, so a basket left on Auto Ship renews at the lower band rather than the promotional rate.
Salty Cat
How much does Salty Cat cost to start?
The lowest entry price in the range is $1, and the brand sits at position 11 of 152 brands ranked on that figure, so the headline number is not the cheapest on the site.
What happens to the price after the first order?
Salty Cat sells on a subscription model, so each box repeats on the same plan until you change or stop it. The price you start on is the one that keeps recurring, and introductory discounts in the wider cat food ranking sit at 15%, so it is worth reading the current offer before judging the ongoing rate.
Sources
PetSmart
- petsmart.com: 16 facts, checked 30 September 2026
- petsmartcorporate.com: 2 facts, checked 30 September 2026
Salty Cat
- saltycat.com: 13 facts, checked 30 September 2026

