Updated 21 October 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Happy and Polly vs PetSmart
Happy and Polly
No. 4 of 149 in online pet stores9.3Pick Happy and Polly for a lower free-delivery threshold ($19 against $49) and more markets (3 against 1).
PetSmart
No. 82 of 149 in online pet stores9.4Pick PetSmart for a longer money-back period (60 days against 30 days).
Key differences
- PetSmart scores higher overall: 9.4 against 9.3.
- Happy and Polly has a lower free-delivery threshold ($19 against $49).
- PetSmart has a longer money-back period (60 days against 30 days).
- Among support channels, only Happy and Polly offers Email, Chat and Community.
- Happy and Polly is available in 2 more countries.
Side by side
| Cost | ||
|---|---|---|
| Free delivery threshold | $19Lowerin the lowest quarter of 34 brands | $49at the median of 34 brands |
| Shipping fee | $6above the median of 28 brands | Not listed |
| Offer | ||
| Pet pharmacy | No | Yes |
| Vet service | No | Yes |
| Loyalty scheme | Yes | Yes |
| Third-party sellers | No | Not listed |
| Markets | Australia, United Kingdom, United States | United States |
| Delivery and service | ||
| Repeat-order discount | 35% | 5% to 35% |
| Same-day delivery | No | Yes |
| Dispatch time | 1 to 3 days | 1 to 3 days |
| Money-back period | 30 daysat the median of 63 brands | 60 daysHigherin the highest quarter of 63 brands |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | PARMEDU CO., LIMITED | PetSmart LLC |
| Headquarters | Hong Kong | United States |
| Founded | 2020 | 1987 |
| Support channels | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre, Community | Phone, Help centre |
| Pet food | ||
| Delivery model | Retail | Retail |
| Price from | $59.99 | $3.09Lower |
| Pet food | ||
| Species | Cat | Dog, Cat |
| Food types | Not listed | Dry, Wet, Fresh cooked, Raw |
| Personalised recipe | Not listed | No |
| Introductory discount | Not listed | 40% |
| Recipes | Not listed | 1,815 |
| Proteins | Not listed | Chicken, Salmon, Beef, Lamb, Turkey |
| Grain-free option | Not listed | Yes |
| Life stages | Not listed | Puppy, Adult, Senior, All |
| Formulated by | Not listed | Not stated |
| Human-grade claim | Not listed | No |
| Pause or cancel online | Not listed | Yes |
Part scores
Happy and Polly
Our verdict on each
Happy and Polly
Happy and Polly suits cat owners who want cheap fountain and litter kit without a subscription or a vet upsell. Autoship takes 35% off, free delivery starts at $19, and devices begin at $59.99.
Read the full Happy and Polly reviewPetSmart
PetSmart suits US pet owners who want food, a pharmacy and vet care in one account rather than a single recipe box. Food starts at $3.09, the Auto Ship schedule carries the repeat discount, and personalised food is an outright no.
Read the full PetSmart reviewIf neither fits
Pros and cons
Happy and Polly
Pros
- Autoship discount of 35% is the strongest of the brands compared on that measure.
- Subscription is not required, so the Moonlight Wireless Smart Water Fountain and the Tofu and Cassava Natural Cat Litter can be bought outright.
- Range covers both a fountain and a litter box, with 45 days of battery on the Moonlight Wireless Smart Water Fountain.
Cons
- Shipping costs $6 on smaller baskets, and the fee is higher than the cheapest brands compared.
- Range is cat only, so a dog household has to look at the wider ranking rather than this brand.
- Warranty on the litter and fountain lines runs 3 months, shorter than the 30 day return window you get on top of it.
PetSmart
Pros
- Pharmacy and a vet service are both yes, so medication and check-ups are handled in the same account as the food order
- Same day is yes and dispatch runs 1 to 3 days, so a shop that runs short mid-week can still be covered
- The dog range holds 1,815 recipes across dry, wet and fresh cooked formats, and a grain free option is yes
Cons
- Personalised food is no, so a dog on an elimination or prescription diet is served by choosing a listed recipe rather than a made one.
- Shipping is limited to the US, so a basket placed from another country sits outside the $49 free delivery threshold.
- The salmon and rice dry recipe lists its formulator as not stated and the human grade claim is no, so the 1,815 recipes behind that shelf carry no named nutritionist or human grade wording to weigh.
Who each suits
Happy and Polly
Who it suits
- Cat households that already know which fountain or litter they want the lowest entry price
- Shoppers who want a discount on repeat consumables without signing up for a subscription
- Multi cat homes fitting a second bowl or an extra litter box
Who should look elsewhere
- Dog owners, since the range is cat only
- Anyone wanting pharmacy medication or a vet service, which this brand does not have
- Shoppers who need same day delivery, since same day is not offered
PetSmart
Who it suits
- US households feeding more than one pet, since the range covers dog and cat from a single delivery
- Owners who want a pharmacy and a vet service handled in the same account as the food order
- Regular Auto Ship buyers who like a wide shelf, with 1,815 dog recipes to pick a repeat order from
Who should look elsewhere
- PetSmart Canada, if the basket ships to Canada, since its free delivery threshold of CAD 49 is priced for that market
- PETstock, if the basket is small or Australian, since its free delivery threshold of AUD 25 is lighter than the $49 asked here
Questions about each
Happy and Polly
How much does delivery cost and when is it free?
Shipping is free from $19. Below that basket size you pay a flat fee of $6, so order runs of litter alongside a fountain to clear the threshold in one go. Dispatch happens within 1 to 3 days, and same day delivery is not offered.
Do I have to sign up for a subscription to get these devices?
No. A subscription is not required for the Moonlight Wireless Smart Water Fountain or the Tofu and Cassava Natural Cat Litter, and the delivery model is retail. You buy the unit outright at $59.99 and up, then reorder consumables whenever you want.
PetSmart
How much does PetSmart food cost to get started?
Dog food on the site starts at $3.09. Prices are set per product, so that figure is a single entry point rather than a typical monthly basket. A loyalty scheme is in place for repeat orders, and returns run 60 days, so a small first bag carries little risk.
Does the Auto Ship discount last, or is the headline discount only for joining?
Two rates sit side by side. Joining Auto Ship is advertised at 40%, while the ongoing schedule takes 5% to 35% off repeat orders. The sign-up saving is the larger of the two, so a basket left on Auto Ship renews at the lower band rather than the promotional rate.


