Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team

Pupper Crust review

Pupper Crust logo

Pupper CrustNo. 101 of 149 in online pet stores

9.0
See alternatives
9.0
out of 10No. 101 of 149 in online pet storesFacts checked 30 Sep 2026

Best for: Treats on a subscription for US dog and cat owners who want to pause or cancel online.

Number of products
72
Free delivery threshold
$49
Pet pharmacy
No
Vet service
No

Alternatives to Pupper Crust

See all 149 ranked →

Our verdict

Pupper Crust suits US pet owners who want personalised treats on a subscription and can pause or cancel orders online. Recipes run to 15 for dog and cat, and returns run for 30 days, so a first order is easy to try.

Fits you if

  • Dog and cat owners in the United States who want a short treat list rather than a general pet shop.
  • Owners who like a personal pick and control over delivery timing, since pausing and cancelling both work online.
  • Shoppers who want to pick among beef, turkey and duck without scrolling a long catalogue.

Look elsewhere if

  • PETstock buyers, whose free delivery threshold is AUD 25 while Pupper Crust ships only in the United States.
  • PetSmart Canada shoppers, whose free delivery threshold of CAD 49 sits in another market.
  • Petbarn buyers, who reach free delivery at AUD 49 outside Pupper Crust’s US.

Key facts

Cost
Free delivery threshold
$49
Price from
$0
Offer
Number of products
72
Pet pharmacy
No
Vet service
No
Loyalty scheme
No
Third-party sellers
No
Personalised recipe
Yes
Recipes
15
Proteins
Beef, Turkey, Duck, Chicken, Salmon, Bison
+1 moreCod
Species
Dog, Cat
Food types
Treats
Markets
United States
Delivery and service
Same-day delivery
No
Money-back period
30 days
Delivery model
Subscription
Pause or cancel online
Yes
Company
Legal entity
Pupper Crust LLC
Headquarters
United States
Support channels
Email, Help centre
Official website
puppercrust.com

Facts checked 30 September 2026, 7 sources

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Personalised treats are on offer, and the range covers beef, turkey and duck.
  • Pausing and cancelling both work online, so you set the rhythm of orders yourself.
  • Everything sold comes from Pupper Crust itself, with no third party sellers on the site.
  • Support runs through email and help centre.

Cons

  • There is no pharmacy and no vet service, so it cannot cover prescriptions or health advice.
  • Same day delivery is not on offer, so a forgotten bag of treats waits for a standard dispatch.
  • There is no loyalty scheme, so repeat orders earn nothing back.

What it does well

Pupper Crust is a narrow shop rather than a full pet superstore. It lists 72 products, and everything on the site is sold by the company itself, with no third party sellers. Orders are covered by a returns window of 30 days, which is the main safety net for a first subscription. It stops short of health services. There is no pharmacy, so no prescription or medicine lines, and no vet service, so no consultations from the shop. Same day delivery is not on offer, so restocking waits on the standard dispatch. There is no loyalty scheme either, so repeat buyers do not earn points.

Who runs it

Pupper Crust LLC is the legal entity behind the site, and it is based in the US. Support runs through email and help centre, so questions are answered in writing or in the help centre, with no phone line among the listed channels. That suits owners who would rather keep a written record of an order change than chase a call.

Questions

What does a first order from Pupper Crust cost?

Pupper Crust lists prices from $0, so a first basket can be a small trial rather than a full food order. The shop covers treats only. Delivery is free once a basket passes $49, and orders can be paused or cancelled online.

Where does Pupper Crust deliver?

Delivery is offered in the United States, and the company behind the site is based in the United States. Orders run as a subscription, so boxes arrive on a set rhythm. Same day delivery is not on offer, which is worth knowing before a last minute restock.

Can I pause or cancel a Pupper Crust subscription?

Yes, pausing and cancelling both work online, so a delivery can be held or stopped from your account without a phone call. Support also runs through email and help centre, so a change can be put in writing if you want a record of it.

How big is the Pupper Crust range?

The shop lists 72 products, and the treat range covers beef, turkey and duck. Recipes run to 15, so choice is focused rather than a long general pet list. Treats are the whole offer, listed as treats.

Is the food personalised at Pupper Crust?

Personalisation is offered, so recipes can be tailored to your pet rather than fixed packs. The personalising applies to treats, so it does not extend to complete meals. The catalogue covers 15 recipes in total.

Does Pupper Crust sell medicine or offer vet advice?

No. There is no pharmacy, so no prescription or medicine lines, and no vet service, so no consultations from the site. Everything is sold by Pupper Crust itself, with no third party sellers, so what you can buy is bounded by the 72 products in the shop.

What is the Pupper Crust returns window?

Returns run for 30 days, which is the main recourse for a first subscription box. Requests go through email and help centre. There is no loyalty scheme, so that window matters more here than it would at a shop with points.

How does the Pupper Crust free delivery threshold compare with rivals?

PetSmart Canada gives free delivery at CAD 49 and Petbarn at AUD 49, each in its own market. PETstock’s threshold is AUD 25, below Pupper Crust’s $49, though Pupper Crust ships only in the United States.

Is there a Pupper Crust loyalty programme?

No, there is no loyalty scheme, so repeat orders do not earn points or tier discounts. Ordering is handled as a subscription instead, and pausing or cancelling online is available. Free delivery begins at $49.

Sources

  • puppercrust.com checked 30 September 2026

    Backs: Headquarters, Loyalty scheme, Personalised recipe, Pet pharmacy, Species

    “Made with love in Austin, TX”

  • puppercrust.com/privacy-policy checked 30 September 2026

    Backs: Markets

    “Our services are primarily intended for users located in the United States”

  • puppercrust.com/product-category/treats checked 30 September 2026

    Backs: Food types, Proteins, Recipes

    “treats - greens & cheddar pretzels”

  • puppercrust.com/product/toys-and-treats-bundle checked 30 September 2026

    Backs: Free delivery threshold, Same-day delivery

    “Free Shipping on Orders Over $49”

  • puppercrust.com/refund_returns checked 30 September 2026

    Backs: Money-back period

    “we will gladly replace it at no additional cost within 30 days”

  • puppercrust.com/shop-all checked 30 September 2026

    Backs: Price from, Number of products

    “st. patrick's leprechaun hat $0”

  • puppercrust.com/terms-of-service checked 30 September 2026

    Backs: Delivery model, Legal entity, Pause or cancel online, Support channels, Third-party sellers, Vet service

    “Subscription boxes available on a monthly, bimonthly, or other selected frequency”

Compiled from 7 source pages, checked 30 September 2026. We did not open an account.

Not listed yet: Shipping fee, Dispatch time.