Start with the market the store serves
The first filter is the simplest one: does the store actually ship to you. PetSmart Canada covers the CA market, and Petbarn and PETstock each cover the AU market. A single market narrows the field fast, so the online pet store rankings are the quickest way to see which stores are open in your country before you read anything else.
Coverage tells you nothing about quality on its own. Inside a single market, the differences that matter sit in a few places: how fast orders leave the warehouse, how much you need to spend to get delivery free, how deep the recurring discount goes, and how long you have to change your mind.
Dispatch speed and the spend that unlocks free delivery
Petbarn dispatches in 1 to 3 days. PetSmart Canada and PETstock are both slightly behind it, with dispatch windows of 2 to 3 days. Across the wider set, dispatch runs up to 7 days, which puts all of these brands in the tighter part of the span.
Thresholds are harder to compare than they look, because each store sets its own level and its own currency. Convert before you compare.
What delivery costs when you fall short of the threshold
If your basket sits under the threshold, the fee matters more than the headline discount.
The practical test is simple. Take your realistic monthly basket, check it against each store’s threshold, and then add the fee for the months you would land. A store with a bigger discount and a higher threshold often costs more for a small or split-up order, while a lower threshold suits irregular top-up orders.
Autoship discounts, intro offers and who holds the cancel button
Recurring-order discounts vary a lot. PetSmart runs an autoship discount of 5% to 35%, PETstock offers 15% on autoship plus an intro offer of 15%, and PetSmart Canada lists 35%. The set-wide span is 5% to 50%, so a deeper cut is available elsewhere if the biggest figure is what you are after.
A discount is only worth taking if you can exit it easily. PETstock operates a subscription model, so check the commitment before you sign up, and note that PETstock lets you pause or cancel an order online. Work out your own consumption pace first: pet food sizes vary a lot, and a subscription you cannot slow down turns a saving into wasted stock.
Returns window and how hard support is to reach
PetSmart Canada gives you 60 days for a money back return, and PETstock lists 28 days. A longer window gives you time to check a food against your pet’s tolerance instead of guessing at the counter.
Support reach tells you how fast you can resolve a problem. Petbarn offers email, chat and phone, PETstock offers phone, chat and help centre, and PetSmart Canada offers phone and help centre. Live chat is the quickest channel for a wrong item, while a phone line suits prescription or pharmacy questions.
Assortment: species, food format and grain free needs
PETstock lists dog and cat in its range and carries dry, wet and freeze dried formats, plus a grain free option for pets that need it. If your pet is on a prescription or veterinary diet, the format list tells you quickly whether a store is worth a deeper look or a skip.
Range size on its own is a weak signal, and the numbers vary enormously between stores. Product counts across the set run 6 to 200,000, so a small catalogue can still be a good match if it holds exactly what your pet eats. Read the Petbarn review and the PETstock review for how each range holds up in practice.
Services around the basket, and how to weigh reliability
Services can decide a comparison on their own. PetSmart Canada and PETstock both run a pharmacy, while PetSmart Canada, Petbarn and PETstock each offer vet services, which means repeat prescriptions and routine checkups can sit with the same company as the food. Each of them runs a loyalty program too, and Petbarn and PETstock both offer same day delivery for urgent top-ups.
For reliability, look behind the storefront. PETstock trades as Petstock Pty Ltd and lists its headquarters as AU, having been founded in 2002, while PetSmart Canada trades as PetSmart LLC with its headquarters listed as US. A long trading history, a named legal entity and published returns terms are a reasonable proxy for a company that will still be there at your next reorder. Read the PetSmart Canada review and the PetSmart review alongside the rankings before you settle on a shortlist.