Updated 17 November 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Top dog treats compared in the United States
Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.
- 73
Wild Earth
Top pickBest for: US households wanting a single subscription for dog and cat food plus treats.
8.5SubscriptionNo2Dried yeast, Potato proteinNot listedNot listed- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US owners feeding adult dogs or cats who want dry, wet and treats covered by the same plan
- Anyone who wants a complete aafco formula put together by a vet nutritionist
Look elsewhere if
- Owners wanting a personalised plan, since personalisation is not offered
- Puppy and senior households, as life stages cover adult
Read review- Price from
- $24.99
- Introductory discount
- 20%
- Recipes
- 2
- Proteins
- Dried yeast, Potato protein
- 74
Bully Sticks Direct
Top pickBest for: US dog owners buying natural chews they will reorder on a set schedule.
8.5SubscriptionNoNot listedBeef, Goose, Camel +3YesNot listed- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners whose dog does not do well on beef and needs another protein.
- Shoppers who would rather set a delivery schedule than reorder each time.
Look elsewhere if
- Buyers outside the US, where the brand does not ship.
- Shoppers who need frozen shipping or a personalized recipe.
Read review- Price from
- $22.99
- Introductory discount
- 20%
- Proteins
- Beef, Goose, Camel, and 3 more
- Cost8.2
- Offer8.9
- Trust8.3
- 758.4SubscriptionNo2Chicken, TunaNot listedNot listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US dog and cat owners who know which treats their pet tolerates and want them on a schedule.
- Grain free households, since a grain free option is available.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone feeding a complete diet, since PETstock carries dry, wet and freeze dried rather than treats alone.
- Raw feeding households, since Bella + Duke lists raw and treats.
Read review- Price from
- $30
- Introductory discount
- 10%
- Recipes
- 2
- Proteins
- Chicken, Tuna
- 76
8.1SubscriptionNot listedNot listedChickenNot listedNot listed- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners managing picky eating at mealtime
- People who love pets and value rescue giving
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers seeking complete daily meal plans
Read review- Proteins
- Chicken
- Support channels
- 77
ACANA
Top pickBest for: ACANA fits owners who buy in batches from a shop rather than committing to a subscription box.
Not ratedRetailNo58Beef, Bison, Chicken +6YesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Multi-pet households feeding a dog and a cat, since dog and cat is listed together.
- Shoppers who prefer retail shops to a subscription box and like choosing in person.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat-first households, since PetPlate centres on dog while ACANA spreads its range across dog and cat.
- Buyers who want dog food matched to a single pet, since Personalised is no and Ollie builds its plans around dog.
Read review- Recipes
- 58
- Proteins
- Beef, Bison, Chicken, and 6 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- 78

Applaws
Top pickBest for: Owners who want dry, wet and treats for dog and cat, bought from shops rather than a delivery subscription.
Not ratedRetailNoNot listedChicken, Beef, Lamb +2YesComplementary- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog and cat owners who want dry, wet and treats bought in a shop rather than a delivery box.
- Anyone feeding a puppy, adult or senior dog from the puppy, adult and senior range, especially where a grain free option is needed.
Look elsewhere if
- Owners who want the bowl adjusted per dog: Applaws offers no personalised food, and Ollie and tails.com are the names to put side by side for that.
- Shoppers who want a complete diet with a stated formulator behind it, since the listed nutrition standard is complementary and formulation is not stated. PetPlate is one of the other names here to line up against it.
Read review- Proteins
- Chicken, Beef, Lamb, and 2 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complementary
- Energy per 100 g
- 48.8 kcals
- 79

Blue Buffalo
Top pickBest for: US owners of dog and cat who buy dry, wet and treats in a shop rather than on a subscription.
Not ratedRetailNoNot listedChicken, Beef, FishYesNot listed- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US households feeding dog and cat from the same brand, where Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com are listed for dogs only.
- Owners of puppy, adult and senior dogs and cats who want dry, wet and treats bought in their usual pet shop.
Look elsewhere if
- Dog-only households that do not also have a cat: Ollie (dog), PetPlate and tails.com (dog) are each dog only, so a narrower range is on the table there.
- Anyone after a recurring delivery plan or frozen formats: Blue Buffalo is retail and does not ship frozen, so Ollie and tails.com are the nearer shortlist for a dog owner who wants something other than a shop bought bag.
Read review- Proteins
- Chicken, Beef, Fish
- Formulated by
- Vet nutritionist
- Human-grade claim
- No
- 80

Canidae
Top pickBest for: Dog and cat owners in the US and Canada who buy standard complete food off the shelf rather than on a plan.
Not ratedRetailNoNot listedChicken, Turkey, Lamb +2YesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Mixed dog and cat households, since dog and cat covers both under a single brand.
- Shoppers who want a vet nutritionist recipe to complete aafco standard they can pick off a shelf rather than have built for them.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone who wants a diet built around an individual pet: Canidae runs no personalised plans, where Ollie sets each dog's plan from a quiz.
- Cat owners after a cat specialist: Ollie and PetPlate are listed for dog and dog, while Canidae splits dry, wet and treats across dog and cat.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 15%
- Proteins
- Chicken, Turkey, Lamb, and 2 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- 81
Not ratedSubscriptionYes32Not listedYesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Mixed dog and cat households, since dog and cat covers both under a single plan.
- Owners who want formulation by a vet nutritionist rather than a general nutritionist.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat households already settled on Ollie or PetPlate, since dog and dog are dog only.
Read review- Recipes
- 32
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Formulated by
- Vet nutritionist
- 82

Natural Balance
Top pickBest for: Shelf buyers who want a grain free option with named limited ingredient proteins.
Not ratedRetailNot listedNot listedSalmon, Duck, BisonYesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners of a dog with a sensitive stomach who has done better on a limited ingredient recipe built around salmon, duck and bison.
- Households that prefer to pick a bag up in a shop, since buying runs through retail channels.
Look elsewhere if
- Puppy and senior households who need a stated life stage. The named recipe is built for adult dogs, and tails.com spans dog food from pup to senior.
Read review- Proteins
- Salmon, Duck, Bison
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Energy per 100 g
- 336 kcals
- Protein
- 24%
- 83

Nulo
Top pickBest for: Grain free dog and cat food bought as a retail bag in US, CA and IT, not a subscription.
Not ratedRetailNoNot listedTurkey, Salmon, TroutYesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners who want dry, wet and treats choices with a grain free option under the same brand.
- People whose dog moves through puppy, adult and senior and who want one nutrition standard across those stages.
Look elsewhere if
- Owners who want a set recurring box: retail keeps this a bag at a time and pause cancel online is not available, so repeat ordering stays manual.
Read review- Proteins
- Turkey, Salmon, Trout
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Energy per 100 g
- 361.4 kcals
- 84

PEDIGREE
Top pickBest for: Dog owners who want a familiar dry and wet range they can pick up in a shop rather than have delivered.
Not ratedRetailNo14Beef, Chicken, Turkey +1NoComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners feeding a dog through every stage in puppy, adult and senior without changing brand.
- Shoppers who want dry, wet and treats in a single brand and would rather leave the shop with the food than wait for a box.
Look elsewhere if
- Ollie buyers who want fresh cooked, since Ollie's range is fresh cooked and dry and Pedigree does not list that format.
- PetPlate shoppers who want fresh cooked alongside wet and treats, which PetPlate covers with fresh cooked, dry and wet.
Read review- Recipes
- 14
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and 1 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO