Updated 17 November 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Top dog treats compared in the United States
Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.
- 61
Smallbatch Pets
Top pickBest for: Owners in the US market who want raw and freeze-dried food plus treats for dogs and cats, ordered as needed.
8.7$14.99RetailNoBeef, Chicken, Turkey +7YesNot listedNot listed- Price from
- $14.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Households feeding a dog and a cat from a single basket, since dog and cat covers both where PetPlate covers dog only.
- Owners after raw and freeze-dried food plus treats in one shop, given fresh cooked, raw and freeze dried sold under a retail model.
Look elsewhere if
- Owners who want meals matched to a specific pet: Personalised is no, so a personalised service fits that need better.
- Single-dog households after a narrower catalogue: tails.com covers dog only, while Smallbatch Pets mixes dog and cat.
Read review- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and 7 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Cost8.4
- Offer8.6
- Trust9.2
- 62

Smalls
Top pickBest for: Cat owners in the US who want personalised portions on a single subscription.
8.7$15.00SubscriptionYesBeef, Chicken, Pork +3Not listed50%5- Price from
- $15
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Cat owners in the US who want fresh meals, freeze-dried food and treats from the same brand.
- People who like portions set for their own cat rather than a fixed recipe for every cat of the same age.
Look elsewhere if
- Dog owners, who should start with Ollie, since Smalls is a cat food brand and Ollie is listed for dogs.
- Households feeding cats and dogs together, since PetPlate is listed for dogs where Smalls covers cats only.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 50%
- Recipes
- 5
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Pork, and 3 more
- Cost8.4
- Offer9.3
- Trust8.4
- 63
Tuft & Paw
Top pickBest for: Cat owners in the US and Canada who want wet food and treats on a set subscription.
8.7$12.00SubscriptionNoChicken, Rabbit, Turkey +2Not listed25%3- Price from
- $12
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Cat owners in the US and Canada who want wet food and treats under a set subscription.
- Shoppers who prefer a short list of 3 recipes over a large catalogue.
Look elsewhere if
- Dog owners, since Bella + Duke covers dog and cat while Tuft & Paw's range is cat.
- Buyers who want freeze-dried food, since Salty Cat sells freeze dried, wet and treats against Tuft & Paw's wet and treats.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 25%
- Recipes
- 3
- Proteins
- Chicken, Rabbit, Turkey, and 2 more
- 64

Lord Jameson
Top pickBest for: Dog owners who want a broad treat list and no subscription: Lord Jameson starts at $9.99 for a one-off order.
8.6$9.99One offNoNot listedNoNot listed53- Price from
- $9.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- One off
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Households feeding dogs of any age, since life stages are listed as all.
Look elsewhere if
- Buyers who want meals as well as treats: PetPlate covers fresh cooked, dry and wet, so it fills a full basket where this range stays in treats.
- Owners who prefer a repeating order they can skip or stop: tails.com covers dry, wet and treats and is the better fit for a regular meal routine.
Read review- Recipes
- 53
- Grain-free option
- No
- Protein
- 7.5%
- Cost8.6
- Offer8.8
- Trust8.2
- 65

PupGum
Top pickBest for: Dog owners on a subscription who want personalised turkey treats at a discounted opening price.
8.6$26.35SubscriptionYesTurkeyNot listed45%3- Price from
- $26.35
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners who treat training as a routine and prefer a subscription that lands without reordering.
- Shoppers who like a short ingredient list: 3 recipes, all built on turkey.
Look elsewhere if
- PetPlate buyers, since it lists fresh cooked, dry and wet and covers more than treats.
- tails.com shoppers who want dry, wet and treats ordered together with the treats.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 45%
- Recipes
- 3
- Proteins
- Turkey
- 66
Vital Essentials
Top pickBest for: Freeze-dried and raw food with a grain free option for US dogs and cats.
8.6$16.99SubscriptionNoBeef, Turkey, Lamb +4YesNot listedNot listed- Price from
- $16.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Grain free feeders who want treats and meals from the same supplier, given the freeze dried, raw and treats list.
- Owners happy to order ahead, since orders run on subscription terms.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone who needs a plan built around an individual animal: Personalised is a no here, and Ollie covers dogs, so a dog-only range is the place to compare on that point.
- Owners who want a human grade claim on the pack: the human grade claim is a no, and PetPlate covers dogs, so check that range's wording before switching.
Read review- Proteins
- Beef, Turkey, Lamb, and 4 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Formulated by
- Not stated
- 67
8.5$19.99One offNoBeef, Pork, PoultryYes10%Not listed- Price from
- $19.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- One off
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners who treat as an occasional extra rather than part of the daily diet
- Shoppers who want one bag at a time and no recurring delivery
Look elsewhere if
- Cat owners, since Salty Cat covers cat and Bonez is listed for dog
- Anyone feeding a complete diet, since PetPlate and tails.com carry full food types alongside treats
Read review- Introductory discount
- 10%
- Proteins
- Beef, Pork, Poultry
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Cost8.2
- Offer8.7
- Trust8.8
- 68

Montana Dog Food Co
Top pickBest for: Freeze-dried raw feeding in the US on a short, easy to manage recipe list.
8.5$19.99SubscriptionNoBeef, Chicken, TroutNot listed20%3- Price from
- $19.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US dog owners who want raw and freeze-dried food together with treats in the same range, since it covers freeze dried, raw and treats.
- Owners whose dogs need a grain free option and who prefer to pause or cancel a recurring delivery online.
Look elsewhere if
- Fresh-cooked feeders: Ollie runs fresh cooked and dry and PetPlate runs fresh cooked, dry and wet, both covering styles that sit outside Montana's freeze dried, raw and treats range.
- Wet and dry shoppers: tails.com offers dry, wet and treats, while Montana's range is freeze dried, raw and treats, so households wanting tinned or kibble alongside treats will find more choice there.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 20%
- Recipes
- 3
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Trout
- 69
Paw Up
Top pickBest for: Owners in US keeping a dog and a cat, buying one off bags across dry, freeze dried and treats.
8.5$15.99One offNoChicken, Duck, Beef +1YesNot listedNot listed- Price from
- $15.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- One off
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Households in US that keep a dog and a cat and want dry, freeze dried and treats under one roof.
- Puppy and adult owners covered by puppy and adult who prefer buying a bag when they need it rather than on a repeat cycle.
Look elsewhere if
- A dog only household, where Ollie (dog) or PetPlate makes a shorter shortlist.
- Buyers who want a subscription with an introductory offer, since ordering is one off and carries no renewal step.
Read review- Proteins
- Chicken, Duck, Beef, and 1 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Formulated by
- Not stated
- 70

Pupford
Top pickBest for: US dog owners after a short freeze-dried and treat range bought as one off orders, with a 30 day refund window.
8.5$9.99One offNoBeef, Chicken, Salmon +1Not listed10%3- Price from
- $9.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- One off
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US dog owners who want a short, protein clear freeze-dried range with a 30 day refund window on the first order.
- Owners of dog who want to add treats without a subscription, since orders are placed as one off purchases.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat households, who should start with Salty Cat, listed as cat, since Pupford's range is dog only.
- Mixed pet homes that want dog and cat covered in one place, because Bella + Duke lists dog and cat.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 10%
- Recipes
- 3
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Salmon, and 1 more
- Cost8.6
- Offer8.5
- Trust8.4
- 71

Raised Right
Top pickBest for: US owners of dogs or cats who want fresh-cooked or air-dried food on a flexible subscription.
8.5Not listedSubscriptionYesTurkey, Beef, PorkNot listedNot listedNot listed- Price from
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US owners feeding an adult dog or puppy and wanting air-dried or fresh-cooked fresh cooked, air dried and treats on a subscription.
- Pet owners who want recipes vet nutritionist rather than a generic formula.
Look elsewhere if
- UK buyers who want delivery, since US is the only market covered.
- Owners of senior pets, because puppy and adult do not include that stage.
Read review- Proteins
- Turkey, Beef, Pork
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Energy per 100 g
- 385.7 kcals
- Protein
- 54%
- 72

Silver Paw
Top pickBest for: US dog owners who want a single grain free beef chew on a subscription they can pause or cancel online.
8.5$17.99SubscriptionNoBeefYesNot listed1- Price from
- $17.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US dog owners buying a chew on a repeat order rather than a full meal, since delivery is limited to US.
- Owners of dogs that need a grain free treat, since a grain free option is offered.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat owners, because Salty Cat is built around cat while Silver Paw lists dog.
- Buyers who want a complete meal in the same order, because tails.com covers dry, wet and treats and Silver Paw covers treats.
Read review- Recipes
- 1
- Proteins
- Beef
- Grain-free option
- Yes