Updated 18 October 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Top dog food brands compared in the United States
Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.
- 25
Instinct Pet Food
Top pickBest for: Grain free raw and freeze-dried food for dogs and cats, bought as needed.
9.0$8.99RetailNoBeef, Lamb, Chicken +2YesNot listedNot listed- Price from
- $8.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners in the US feeding raw or freeze-dried food who want a grain free option and to buy packs as they need them
- Cat households that want raw, freeze-dried, dry, wet and treats from the same brand, since Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com cover dogs only
Look elsewhere if
- Cat households narrowing the field: Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com list dogs, while Instinct Pet Food covers dog and cat across raw, freeze dried and dry.
Read review- Proteins
- Beef, Lamb, Chicken, and 2 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Cost8.8
- Offer9.0
- Trust9.3
- 26
JustFoodForDogs
Top pickBest for: Frozen, vet nutritionist formulated food for US dogs and cats, with a strong joining discount and online cancellation.
9.0$9.99SubscriptionYesChicken, Beef, Fish +3Not listed1550%- Price from
- $9.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US dog and cat households happy with a single market and a subscription rhythm (dog and cat, US, subscription).
- Owners feeding puppies or adult dogs who want complete food from a vet nutritionist.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat-first households, since Ollie and tails.com list dogs only.
- Owners outside US, where PetPlace covers a single market and Ollie is the comparison worth making first.
Read review- Recipes
- 15
- Introductory discount
- 50%
- Proteins
- Chicken, Beef, Fish, and 3 more
- 27
Nom Nom
Top pickBest for: Personalized fresh-cooked meals with a vet nutritionist behind the recipe sheet.
9.0$9.99SubscriptionYesTurkey, Beef, Chicken +2Not listed825%- Price from
- $9.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners in the US who want their dog's portion worked out for them and a fresh-cooked range formulated by a vet nutritionist.
- Readers who want complete AAFCO meals and treats from one supplier rather than a separate order for each.
Look elsewhere if
- Readers who prefer food that sits on a shelf, since tails.com lists dry, wet and treats with no fresh-cooked meals to thaw.
- Buyers who want dry food alongside fresh-cooked, since Ollie lists fresh cooked and dry where the Nom Nom range stops at fresh cooked and treats.
Read review- Recipes
- 8
- Introductory discount
- 25%
- Proteins
- Turkey, Beef, Chicken, and 2 more
- 28
Open Farm
Top pickBest for: Households that want dog and cat food, several formats and online subscription control from one Canadian brand.
9.0$9.99SubscriptionYesBeef, Chicken, Turkey +8YesNot listed25%- Price from
- $9.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners who want several formats, fresh cooked, raw and freeze dried, from one subscription
- Cat households that want a single supplier covering dog and cat
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers who want a one off purchase instead of a subscription, since delivery is subscription only
- Anyone outside US and CA who needs home delivery
Read review- Introductory discount
- 25%
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and 8 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- 29

Raw Paws Pet Food
Top pickBest for: US owners wanting raw, freeze-dried, dry and treats on one autoship plan.
9.0$7.99SubscriptionYesBeef, Chicken, Duck +7Not listed1915%- Price from
- $7.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US owners feeding raw who also want freeze-dried, dry and treats covered in the same place
- Households that prefer an autoship plan they can pause or cancel from the account
Look elsewhere if
- Cat-first households, since Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com list dog, dog and dog only, against dog and cat here
- Buyers who want one complete ration on its own, since the recipes are labelled complementary
Read review- Recipes
- 19
- Introductory discount
- 15%
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Duck, and 7 more
- Cost8.9
- Offer9.3
- Trust8.6
- 30

Steve's Real Food
Top pickBest for: Adult dogs and cats fed raw or freeze-dried food in the US, bought through stockists.
9.0Not listedRetailNoBeef, Chicken, Pork +3Yes6Not listed- Price from
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Adult dog and cat owners in the US who already shop retail for raw or freeze-dried food
- Multi-pet households wanting raw, freeze-dried and treats from one brand, given dog and cat and raw, freeze dried and treats
Look elsewhere if
- Ollie, if personalisation is the deciding factor
- PetPlate, if you want portions tuned to a single dog
Read review- Recipes
- 6
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Pork, and 3 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- 31
We Feed Raw
Top pickBest for: US dog owners who want a personalised raw or freeze-dried subscription with easy pausing.
9.0$9.66SubscriptionYesBeef, Turkey, Chicken +2Yes5Not listed- Price from
- $9.66
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US owners ready to feed raw or freeze-dried and happy with the subscription model
- Households wanting a grain free option with a nutritionist behind the recipes
Look elsewhere if
- Buyers who want dry, wet or treat formats, since tails.com sells dry, wet and treats and this range is raw and freeze-dried
- Owners wanting a wider format spread, since PetPlate covers fresh cooked, dry and wet against raw and freeze dried here
Read review- Recipes
- 5
- Proteins
- Beef, Turkey, Chicken, and 2 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- 32

BIXBI Pet
Top pickBest for: US dog and cat owners wanting shelf-stable and freeze-dried food on a subscription.
8.9$3.99SubscriptionNoBeef, Chicken, Duck +6YesNot listed5%- Price from
- $3.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners of dogs and cats in the US who want dry, wet and freeze-dried options in one place
- People who prefer a grain free option
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone outside the US, since BIXBI Pet serves US only
- Buyers who want personalised recipes, which Ollie offers for dog
Read review- Introductory discount
- 5%
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Duck, and 6 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Cost9.2
- Offer8.7
- Trust8.9
- 33
Brutus Broth
Top pickBest for: A plain subscription box of wet and treats food for adult pets in US and CA.
8.9$6.99SubscriptionNoBeef, Chicken, Pork +1Not listedNot listedNot listed- Price from
- $6.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners in US and CA feeding an adult dog or a cat, since dog and cat pets are covered and Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com each list dog.
- Readers who want to hold a plan from the account, since pause and cancel are online and support runs on email, phone and help centre.
Look elsewhere if
- Readers who want a dog-only brand: Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com each list dog only, while Brutus Broth covers dog and cat.
- Puppy and senior households: adult covers adult pets, and the subscription box is the only buying route, so a reader feeding across life stages needs more than one plan.
Read review- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Pork, and 1 more
- Formulated by
- Not stated
- Human-grade claim
- Yes
- Cost9.0
- Offer9.1
- Trust8.5
- 34

Carnilove
Top pickBest for: Dog owners after a grain free dry food plan with a decent first order discount.
8.9€9.99SubscriptionYesTurkey, Salmon, Duck +4YesNot listed25%- Price from
- €9.99
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners moving to grain free feeding who want wet, dry, treats and freeze dried in one subscription.
- Households that want to pause or cancel a delivery online between boxes.
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers who only want one bag and no recurring delivery, where a one-off brand such as Ollie fits better.
- Owners who need a named vet nutritionist on the label, where a brand with stated formulation suits better.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 25%
- Proteins
- Turkey, Salmon, Duck, and 4 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- 35
Eukanuba
Top pickBest for: Dog owners who buy bag by bag and want one established maker for both kibble and wet food.
8.9Not listedRetailNoChicken, Lamb, BeefNo28Not listed- Price from
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Households feeding a dog through puppy, adult and senior without changing brand at each stage.
Look elsewhere if
- Fresh food fans: Ollie lists fresh cooked and dry, which Eukanuba's dry and wet does not cover.
- Treat shoppers: PetPlate lists fresh cooked, dry and wet and Tails lists dry, wet and treats, wider format spreads than Eukanuba's dry and wet.
Read review- Recipes
- 28
- Proteins
- Chicken, Lamb, Beef
- Grain-free option
- No
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- 36
ORIJEN
Top pickBest for: Shoppers who buy in stores and want a grain free range covering dry, wet and freeze dried for dog and cat.
8.9Not listedRetailNoBeef, Bison, Boar +10Yes54Not listed- Price from
- Not listed
- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners of dogs and cats who want one maker across dog and cat and a grain free option.
- Shoppers who prefer buying in stores and setting their own order rhythm.
Look elsewhere if
- PetPlate: when no cat lives in the home and a smaller catalogue suits, PetPlate lists dog next to ORIJEN's dog and cat.
- tails.com: tails.com lists dog, which makes it the simpler fit for a single dog household.
Read review- Recipes
- 54
- Proteins
- Beef, Bison, Boar, and 10 more
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO