Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Top dog food brands compared in the United States
Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.
- 73

Blue Buffalo
Top pickBest for: US owners of dog and cat who buy dry, wet and treats in a shop rather than on a subscription.
Not ratedRetailNoChicken, Beef, FishYesNot listed- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US households feeding dog and cat from the same brand, where Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com are listed for dogs only.
- Owners of puppy, adult and senior dogs and cats who want dry, wet and treats bought in their usual pet shop.
Look elsewhere if
- Dog-only households that do not also have a cat: Ollie (dog), PetPlate and tails.com (dog) are each dog only, so a narrower range is on the table there.
- Anyone after a recurring delivery plan or frozen formats: Blue Buffalo is retail and does not ship frozen, so Ollie and tails.com are the nearer shortlist for a dog owner who wants something other than a shop bought bag.
Read review- Proteins
- Chicken, Beef, Fish
- Formulated by
- Vet nutritionist
- Human-grade claim
- No
- 74

Canidae
Top pickBest for: Dog and cat owners in the US and Canada who buy standard complete food off the shelf rather than on a plan.
Not ratedRetailNoChicken, Turkey, Lamb +2YesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Mixed dog and cat households, since dog and cat covers both under a single brand.
- Shoppers who want a vet nutritionist recipe to complete aafco standard they can pick off a shelf rather than have built for them.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone who wants a diet built around an individual pet: Canidae runs no personalised plans, where Ollie sets each dog's plan from a quiz.
- Cat owners after a cat specialist: Ollie and PetPlate are listed for dog and dog, while Canidae splits dry, wet and treats across dog and cat.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 15%
- Proteins
- Chicken, Turkey, Lamb, and 2 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- 75
Not ratedSubscriptionYesNot listedYesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Mixed dog and cat households, since dog and cat covers both under a single plan.
- Owners who want formulation by a vet nutritionist rather than a general nutritionist.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat households already settled on Ollie or PetPlate, since dog and dog are dog only.
Read review- Recipes
- 32
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Formulated by
- Vet nutritionist
- 76

Hill's
Top pickBest for: Owners who want a familiar brand in the aisle and a choice of recipes for dogs and cats.
Not ratedRetailNot listedNot listedNot listedNot listed- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog and cat owners who want one familiar brand for both pets
- Shoppers who prefer buying food in person to a recurring delivery
Look elsewhere if
- Dog only buyers looking for a different range, since Ollie covers dog and PetPlate the same
- Shoppers who want a pausable subscription, as the model is retail and tails.com covers dog
Read review- Recalls
- 2019-01-31: Hill's Prescription dog food and wet Science Diet - Elevated levels of vitamin D, 2014-06-02: Science Diet Adult Small and Toy Breed dry dog food - potential salmonella contamination, 2007-03-16: Science Diet Savory Cuts canned cat food - melamine contamination
- Legal entity
- Hill's Pet Nutrition, Inc.
- Headquarters
- United States
- Founded
- 1907
- 77

Natural Balance
Top pickBest for: Shelf buyers who want a grain free option with named limited ingredient proteins.
Not ratedRetailNot listedSalmon, Duck, BisonYesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners of a dog with a sensitive stomach who has done better on a limited ingredient recipe built around salmon, duck and bison.
- Households that prefer to pick a bag up in a shop, since buying runs through retail channels.
Look elsewhere if
- Puppy and senior households who need a stated life stage. The named recipe is built for adult dogs, and tails.com spans dog food from pup to senior.
Read review- Proteins
- Salmon, Duck, Bison
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Energy per 100 g
- 336 kcals
- Protein
- 24%
- 78

Nulo
Top pickBest for: Grain free dog and cat food bought as a retail bag in US, CA and IT, not a subscription.
Not ratedRetailNoTurkey, Salmon, TroutYesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners who want dry, wet and treats choices with a grain free option under the same brand.
- People whose dog moves through puppy, adult and senior and who want one nutrition standard across those stages.
Look elsewhere if
- Owners who want a set recurring box: retail keeps this a bag at a time and pause cancel online is not available, so repeat ordering stays manual.
Read review- Proteins
- Turkey, Salmon, Trout
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Energy per 100 g
- 361.4 kcals
- 79

PEDIGREE
Top pickBest for: Dog owners who want a familiar dry and wet range they can pick up in a shop rather than have delivered.
Not ratedRetailNoBeef, Chicken, Turkey +1NoComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners feeding a dog through every stage in puppy, adult and senior without changing brand.
- Shoppers who want dry, wet and treats in a single brand and would rather leave the shop with the food than wait for a box.
Look elsewhere if
- Ollie buyers who want fresh cooked, since Ollie's range is fresh cooked and dry and Pedigree does not list that format.
- PetPlate shoppers who want fresh cooked alongside wet and treats, which PetPlate covers with fresh cooked, dry and wet.
Read review- Recipes
- 14
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and 1 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- 80
Pets Deli
Top pickBest for: Mixed dog and cat households wanting one supplier for dry, wet and treats
Not ratedNot listedNot listedNot listedYesNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Personalised recipe
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Mixed dog and cat households who prefer one supplier across dry, wet and treats
- Owners whose dog needs a grain free option and who value reachable support
Look elsewhere if
- Strict budget shoppers who will start cheaper with Ollie
- Pet owners wanting fresh, raw or freeze dried food, where PetPlate fits better
Read review- Legal entity
- Pets Deli Tonius GmbH
- Headquarters
- Germany
- Founded
- 2017
- Support channels
- Email, Phone
- 81
Purina
Top pickBest for: Owners who want vet nutritionist formulated food they can buy as needed in the GB.
Not ratedRetailNoChicken, Beef, Lamb +5YesComplete fediaf- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners who want dry, wet and treats food from one brand for dog and cat, covering puppy, adult and senior stages.
- Households that prefer buying in the GB through a retail shop and phoning Nestle Purina Petcare UK&I with a question.
Look elsewhere if
- Personalised feeders: Ollie or PetPlate are the names to weigh when a recipe has to be built around a single dog, since Purina's food is not personalised.
- Fresh cooked and raw feeders: dry, wet and treats is the full format list, so a household wanting raw or chilled meals should weigh tails.com alongside.
Read review- Introductory discount
- 15%
- Proteins
- Chicken, Beef, Lamb, and 5 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete fediaf
- 82

Taste of the Wild
Top pickBest for: Grain free dry and wet food you buy from shops, for dogs and cats, in US, CA and GB
Not ratedRetailNoBison, Venison, Salmon +8YesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Homes with both a dog and a cat, since dog and cat are both covered
- Grain free shoppers who want bison, venison and salmon to choose from
Look elsewhere if
- Owners who want a plan matched to their dog, since personalisation is no here
- Ollie and PetPlate suit people who want regular delivery to the door rather than a shop trip
Read review- Proteins
- Bison, Venison, Salmon, and 8 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Energy per 100 g
- 371.9 kcals
- 83

The Pets Table
Top pickBest for: US dog owners who want a personalised, vet-formulated air-dried or fresh-cooked ration on a subscription.
Not ratedSubscriptionYesNot listedNot listedComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Personalised recipe
- Yes
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US owners who want portions set for an individual dog rather than weighing out each meal
- Feeders who want air-dried food as well as fresh-cooked in the same order
Look elsewhere if
- Cat owners, since dog covers dogs only and no cat range is listed
- Anyone outside the US, since US lists a single market and the other brands listed for comparison sit elsewhere
Read review- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Formulated by
- Vet nutritionist
- Human-grade claim
- Yes
- Pause or cancel online
- Yes
- 84

Wellness Pet Food
Top pickBest for: Owners in US, CA and AU who buy from shops and want a standard complete diet across both species.
Not ratedRetailNoTurkey, Chicken, Duck +6YesComplete AAFCO- Delivery model
- Retail
- Personalised recipe
- No
- Grain-free option
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Households feeding both dogs and cats from one brand across dry, wet and treats formats.
- Anyone who wants a complete aafco standard with vet nutritionist formulation behind the recipe.
Look elsewhere if
- Owners who want a plan they can pause or cancel online, since pause and cancel online is not offered here.
- Anyone who needs a diet personalised to one pet, as personalised feeding is not available.
Read review- Proteins
- Turkey, Chicken, Duck, and 6 more
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
- Protein
- 35%