Start with the price spread
Every brand in this comparison sells on subscription, and the gap between the cheapest and the priciest starting price is wide. A daily figure on its own tells you little, because bag size, dog size and delivery cycle all change what you actually pay.
Discounts move just as much as prices. Intro offers in the range run 5% to 70%, so treat any welcome discount as an introductory subscription rate rather than the price you renew at. Write down the per-day figure for the plan size you would really order, then check what is inside the box.
Fix the format before the brand
Decide how the food is preserved before you pick a brand, because a range may not sell what you expect. PETstock lists dry, wet and freeze dried for dogs, mixing shelf-stable and air-dried options with freeze-dried. Bella + Duke is narrower, with raw and treats for dogs. If your dog needs a specific format, that list shortlists brands faster than any price.
Freeze-dried is not always a dog category. Salty Cat offers freeze dried, wet and treats, but the range covers cat only, so read it as a freeze-dried reference for cat households rather than a dog option. The raw and freeze-dried dog food rankings show which brands cover the format your dog needs.
Read price by plan and billing cycle
An intro offer of 40% sits on top, so the welcome delivery and the renewal are different prices. Get the renewal figure in writing before you commit.
PETstock also sells on subscription, with an autoship saving of 15% on repeat orders, and has traded since 2002. Shipping terms are the steadier part of that offer. The Bella + Duke review and the PETstock review show how each delivery model settles in day to day.
Delivery days, markets and the cold chain
Frozen food makes logistics part of the product. Bella + Duke ships frozen, so its delivery terms matter as much as the recipe, and it sells across GB, NL and BE from a GB base, with the company registered as Bella & Duke Ltd.
PETstock publishes a dispatch window of 2 to 3 days, which is a useful anchor when you are planning around freezer space. Salty Cat sells in a single market, US, so geography rules it out for many readers. Markets are a hard filter rather than a preference, and cold shipping is something to check before you order.
Nutrition detail beats the badge
Analysis values are what let you compare ranges. Bella + Duke’s chicken recipe lists 14.43% protein, 5.04% fat and 98 for energy, under a nutrition standard of complete fediaf. Those figures come from a single recipe, so pull the same numbers for the recipe your dog would eat.
Formulation claims differ too. Bella + Duke says its food is formulated by a nutritionist, while Salty Cat says vet-nutritionist, and both offer a grain free option. Bella + Duke covers puppy, adult and senior, while Salty Cat covers adult, with 24 recipes built around beef, chicken and duck. Bella + Duke’s protein options are chicken, beef and fish.
Support, claims and reliability
When a box arrives late or thawed, the help options decide how fast it gets sorted. Bella + Duke offers email, phone and chat, the widest set of routes here. Salty Cat offers email and help centre, a leaner setup to plan around.
Two claims show up across these ranges: Bella + Duke and Salty Cat both make a human grade claim, and both offer a personalised range built around the individual animal. Read those alongside the nutrition figures rather than on their own, and use the Salty Cat review to see how a personalised range holds up over time.
Where each brand fits
Bella + Duke suits households with a dog at any life stage in the United Kingdom, NL or BE that want raw food and treats on a flexible subscription. The trade-off is the narrowest food list of the three, and the saving lasts only while the new-customer offer applies.
PETstock suits households that want several formats in one place, including dry, wet, air-dried and freeze-dried, plus a repeat-order saving. The trade-off is that freeze-dried sits inside a wider range, so you need to filter it out before comparing like with like.
Salty Cat suits cat households and shows how a freeze-dried, personalised range is built. The trade-off is scope: it is a cat range and will not serve a dog.
Also worth a look: the Tackenberg review and the Natures Menu review for further options, and the Health Extension review for another view on raw formats.