Set the format and life stage filters first
Personalised kibble means the food is matched to your dog rather than chosen from a fixed range. Ollie and PetPlate both confirm personalisation on their own pages. Ollie’s food types run to fresh cooked and dry, while PetPlate lists fresh cooked, dry and wet, so check the format before anything else: a subscription built around fresh-cooked meals is a different commitment from one built around dry food.
tails.com is a useful comparison point alongside the two personalisation brands, and its listing covers dry, wet and treats. Life stage coverage narrows the field too. PetPlate lists all life stages, and tails.com lists puppy, adult and senior. Every brand in this group is dog only, with Ollie listing dog and PetPlate listing dog, so none of the plans needs adapting for another species.
Compare starting prices with the market in mind
Each brand lists a starting price, and the figures are not directly comparable without the market attached. PetPlate covers US while tails.com covers GB, so a number from one listing tells you very little about a plan sold in the other market.
The personalised kibble rankings. A per-day figure is the easier number to budget from, because it holds steady whatever delivery rhythm you pick.
Open the plan page for the brand you like and read the billing period, what a box contains and how often deliveries arrive before you commit. A low starting price only helps if the plan it belongs to is the one you would keep reordering.
Hold every brand to the same formulation standard
All three listings name a vet nutritionist as the formulator: Ollie at vet nutritionist, PetPlate at vet nutritionist and tails.com at vet nutritionist. That shared answer is the baseline to hold any brand to, and a far firmer filter than the language printed on the bag.
Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com all carry a human grade claim, so that one does not separate them. What does separate them is recipe count and protein variety. Ollie offers 5 recipes built around beef, chicken and turkey, and PetPlate offers 7 around beef, chicken and turkey. A wider recipe list gives you more chances of finding something your dog will actually eat and a protein your dog tolerates.
Treat the intro discount as a trial price
Introductory offers are the loudest number on a landing page. Ollie offers 50%, PetPlate offers 65% and tails.com offers 60%. Across the wider set of listings, introductory offers run 10% to 65%, so a headline figure tells you very little about where a brand sits in the market.
An offer usually applies to your opening order only, and the plan price takes over after that. Work out what you would pay on the second and third delivery, then check whether skipping a delivery or pausing changes your rate. Two brands can advertise similar discounts and leave you with very different ongoing costs.
Read the nutrition numbers instead of the front of the bag
The calorie figure is the most useful of the three for portioning, because a dense food and a light food look identical in a bowl and are not the same across a day’s feeding.
PetPlate also states its nutrition standard as complete aafco, and both PetPlate and tails.com list a grain free option. Grain free suits some dogs and is not automatically better, so treat it as a filter you set rather than a prize you chase. The PetPlate review and the tails.com review are worth reading side by side on exactly these points.
Treat delivery, pausing and support as part of reliability
All three brands run on a subscription model, so a plan keeps going until you change it. That makes the exit terms part of the price rather than an afterthought. PetPlate lets you pause or cancel online and offers frozen shipping for the fresh-cooked part of its range. Ollie does not list either of those points, so ask about them directly before you rely on them.
Support is the quieter reliability signal. Ollie offers email, phone and chat, PetPlate offers email, phone and help centre, and tails.com serves its own market. A question that goes unanswered mid-subscription matters more than a headline offer, because a dog food plan is something you stay with for months. The Ollie review covers the brand with the widest support setup in this group.
If you want to widen the shortlist before deciding, the Forthglade review and the Kabo review are useful next reads, and the rankings page keeps every score in the same place.