Updated · KibbleCue Editorial Team

How to choose fresh dog food delivery

Compare fresh dog food delivery on price, formats, formulation and support, with worked examples from Ollie, PetPlate and Dogfy Diet.

Start with the price you actually pay each day

Fresh food plans are sold on subscriptions at Ollie, PetPlate and Dogfy Diet, so the entry price is the first filter.

A cheaper entry point is not the same as a cheaper month, because portion size follows the dog. Work out what each brand charges for the portion your own dog needs, then read the Ollie review and the PetPlate review to see how each plan is built before you commit. Every figure here is a starting point rather than a promise for a specific dog.

Read the delivery model, then the shipping method

Each brand here delivers on a subscription, so pausing and skipping deliveries matters more than it would for a one-off order. PetPlate lets you pause or cancel your subscription online without contacting anyone, and Ollie and Dogfy Diet are subscription services too. If you travel often or your dog’s appetite changes week to week, that control is worth as much as a small price difference.

Frozen shipping is the practical test of whether a fresh brand is built around cold chain logistics. PetPlate and Dogfy Diet both ship frozen. Brands that do not ship frozen are working within a narrower window, and that is a useful line to check in the Dogfy Diet review and the PetPlate review.

Compare formats, because fresh is not the only thing on offer

Every brand here sells fresh-cooked food. Beyond that the shelves widen quickly. Ollie covers fresh-cooked and dry. PetPlate covers fresh-cooked, dry, wet and treats, so a household that wants toppers or a mix of textures can stay with one brand. Dogfy Diet covers fresh-cooked and treats, the narrowest range here.

A wider format list makes a brand easier to stick with as your dog’s needs change, but it also means more recipe choices to read. Use the recipe counts to judge that: Ollie lists 5 recipes and PetPlate lists 7. Small lists are simpler to learn; longer lists give you more room to work around a fussy eater or an ingredient your dog cannot take.

Check who formulated the food and what standard it meets

Ollie, PetPlate and Dogfy Diet are each formulated by a vet-nutritionist, so this one does not separate them. Where they do differ is the stated standard and the grade claim. PetPlate states a complete AAFCO nutrition standard, which gives you a named benchmark to check the label against.

Human grade claims are a separate and vaguer thing, and the brands here answer it differently. Ollie and PetPlate both claim human grade. Dogfy Diet does not make that claim, and it is headquartered in Spain under the legal entity Delicium Petfood S.L. If the grade claim is part of your decision, treat it as a marketing statement to weigh rather than a nutrition guarantee, and check the ingredient list yourself.

Look at protein variety and the numbers on the pack

Ollie and PetPlate share a similar protein line of beef, chicken, turkey and lamb. PetPlate adds venison, giving it a wider spread for dogs that need a novel protein, and Ollie also lists pork. Dogfy Diet’s current recipes are worth reading directly before you assume parity with the other two.

PetPlate publishes per recipe figures that make it easy to compare like with like: its chicken recipe lists 10.8% protein and 4.5% fat, with an energy density of 137.57. Use those to sanity check a portion against your dog’s energy needs rather than trusting the price per day alone.

Weight the intro offer, then ignore it

Introductory discounts in this group run 5% to 65%, which is a wide spread and easy to overvalue. PetPlate offers the largest at 65%, Ollie sits at 50% and Dogfy Diet at 30%. These are first-order discounts that expire, so use one to lower the cost of a trial box and then judge the brand on the standard price.

Line up life stages, personalisation and support

PetPlate’s food is listed for all life stages, which matters for households that will run a dog through puppy years and beyond on the same plan. Ollie and Dogfy Diet are dog-only brands, so a multi-dog or multi-species household would need a second supplier for other pets.

Personalisation is a feature both PetPlate and Ollie offer, with portion and delivery matched to the individual dog. On support, Ollie is the broadest of the group: email, phone and chat. PetPlate offers email, phone and help centre. Breadth matters most when something goes wrong with a delivery, since a missed box or a rejected pallet is the moment you need a human on the other end.

Put the shortlist together

Start from the Fresh dog food delivery rankings to see where Ollie, PetPlate and Dogfy Diet sit against other delivery brands, then read the individual reviews for the detail. PetPlate suits readers who want one brand to cover fresh, dry, wet and treats, a named nutrition standard and online subscription control. Ollie suits readers who want the widest support options and a personalised plan. Dogfy Diet suits readers who want fresh food and treats on subscription with frozen shipping and should check its recipes directly.

If another brand looks close on paper, the Kabo review, the DASH Dog Food review and the Health Extension review follow the same structure, so you can apply the same price, format and support checks to them.

See the full ranking: Top fresh dog food delivery compared →

Sources