Price first, then the size of the discount
Every brand in this comparison runs on the same billing rhythm. Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com all use subscription delivery, so the plan renews in the same way and the honest comparison is about what each bowl costs over a month rather than about billing style.
Starting prices are the quickest way into the comparison. A headline price means little on its own, so put the per-day figure next to your dog’s size before you commit.
Intro offers are where most people misread the price
PetPlate offers 65% off, tails.com offers 60% and Ollie offers 50%. The discount span across dog food brands is 2% to 70%, so all of them sit near the top of the market instead of standing apart from it. A large welcome discount is a price cut for the first cycle only, so work out what the box costs once the intro period ends.
That post-intro figure is the one to hold onto. The Dog food brands ranking shows how the leading options price themselves after their welcome period, and reading it next to your own basket is quicker than chasing individual promotions.
Check which market you can actually be served
This filter cuts the shortlist down before you read any ingredient list. PetPlate ships to US, while tails.com ships to GB. Ollie has no market listed, which is an open question worth putting to the team before you plan a monthly basket.
tails.com is run as Tailsco Ltd, and a named operating entity tells you who stands behind a delivery when something goes wrong. Every brand here also lists dogs as the animal it serves, so nothing in this comparison gets past the question of whether the food suits your dog at all.
Format decides the day-to-day logistics
Formats change how you store, serve and travel with the food, and they differ more than the marketing suggests. Ollie lists fresh cooked and dry formats. PetPlate lists fresh cooked, dry and wet formats, the widest shelf of the brands here. tails.com lists dry, wet and treats formats and freshly cooked food is not among them, so anyone set on cooked meals is narrowing the field to Ollie or PetPlate.
PetPlate also ships frozen, and that is the running cost of fresh-cooked food. Frozen boxes need freezer space, and a delivery has to arrive intact to be usable. Chilled meals, pouches and dry food suit different households, so decide which constraint annoys you least before you start comparing numbers.
Energy density matters as much as the price per box
Dogs of the same size can eat very different amounts of food and still take in very different amounts of energy, which is where the per-day price stops being the whole story. PetPlate publishes protein at 10.8% and fat at 4.5%, and names its nutrition standard as complete aafco. Those figures let you test a claim against the portion your dog actually eats.
Neither Ollie nor tails.com publishes a matching calorie, protein and fat set, so this is where the brands are genuinely uneven. Ask either one for the energy density and the guaranteed analysis of the recipe you are considering, then weigh the answer as part of the decision. A transparent recipe makes a price easier to trust than a discount does, and the PetPlate review sets those numbers against the rest of its range.
Life stages narrow the field fast
Puppies, adults and seniors do not eat the same thing, so the life stages a brand will feed are a hard filter. tails.com lists puppy, adult and senior, the most explicit answer of the brands here. PetPlate lists all, so it covers a puppy through to a senior. Ollie carries no life stage entry, and that gap is worth asking about directly rather than assuming.
Recipe count and protein variety are softer signals, but they show how easily you can rotate. Ollie offers 5 recipes and PetPlate 7, drawn from overlapping proteins: Ollie and PetPlate both list beef, chicken and turkey. A broader list helps with a picky eater and gives you an exit route when a recipe stops working.
Claims to interrogate, and who set the recipe
Marketing language is easy to borrow, so check what each brand actually states. Every brand here describes its food as human grade, and every brand names the same role for recipe setting: vet nutritionist. Those are claims rather than independently verified results, so treat them as the starting point for your own questions rather than the end of them.
A grain free option is offered by PetPlate and by tails.com, and is not listed for Ollie and PetPlate also offer personalised portions, so if your dog needs a precise amount, that evidence alone takes tails.com off the shortlist. The Dogfy Diet and Forthglade profiles show very different approaches to portioning across the wider category.
Delivery, support and the practical exit
Every brand on this list sells on subscription, which means the quiet costs sit at renewal, cancellation and support. PetPlate allows you to pause or cancel online, which removes the usual friction from a trial. tails.com and Ollie do not spell out the same cancel detail, so ask how quickly a plan can be stopped before you start, not after the first box lands.
Support is a reliability signal as much as a convenience one. Ollie offers email, phone and chat and PetPlate offers email, phone and help centre, with live chat offered only by Ollie here, while tails.com gives less detail on how to reach it. A brand that answers quickly is easier to hold accountable when a delivery goes wrong, and the Kabo and PETstock reviews show how much support quality varies across the category. The tails.com profile is the place to check the delivery side for anyone ordering within its market.