Start with the format your cat will actually eat
The first filter is the one your cat decides for you, and that is format. Salty Cat lists freeze dried, wet and treats for sale, while PETstock lists dry, wet and freeze dried. Cats that settle on wet food often refuse dry kibble, and a cat raised on kibble may turn its nose up at a new texture, so a format mismatch ends the comparison before it starts. Work through the cat food rankings and check what each brand actually sells for cats before you read a single price.
Format also decides what you need at home. Bella + Duke sells raw and treats and ships them frozen, so a freezer and a thawing routine come with the order, while a dry or canned format only needs a cupboard. Two of the three brands here also offer a personalised plan, which earns its place when your cat is selective or has a dietary condition already discussed with your vet, and adds nothing when it will eat anything.
Compare price per day, not just the entry price
The entry price is the easiest number to misread. Those two figures are not comparable until you know the pack size, the currency and the plan each one belongs to.
A per day figure is more useful for a cat, because the same bag feeds a small cat for weeks and a large one for days.
Then read the discount mechanics. Bella + Duke advertises an intro offer of 40%, and PETstock’s autoship, a subscription option, takes 15% off repeat orders. Intro offers across the brands tracked here run 2% to 70%. An intro price only helps if you can see what the second delivery costs and can leave afterwards without a phone call.
Read the ingredient and nutrition facts side by side
Protein variety matters because cats tire of the same flavour and because some react to one protein. Salty Cat names beef, chicken and duck on its ingredients and offers 24 recipes. Bella + Duke names chicken, beef and fish, so both brands let you rotate proteins rather than committing to a single meat.
Analysis figures beat marketing phrases. The chicken complete recipe listed for Bella + Duke’s dogs shows 98 kcal as its energy value, with protein of 14.43% and fat of 5.04%, and is described as a complete nutrition standard. Salty Cat’s recipes are formulated by a vet nutritionist rather than a nutritionist, which is a different kind of claim to hold against the label.
Two phrases keep reappearing in this group and both are easy to over read. A grain free option is listed by Salty Cat and by Bella + Duke, and both also make a human grade claim. Those phrases describe what is absent and the grade of the raw material, not whether a food is complete, so always set them beside the nutrition standard and the analysis numbers.
Match life stage and species before anything else
Salty Cat’s cat food is listed for adult cats, so a kitten or a senior points straight at a different product. Bella + Duke covers puppy, adult and senior stages, and its range is listed for dog and cat, so one company can feed a cat and a dog household. Life stage is the cheapest filter you have because it deletes options before you spend time on prices.
For the detail behind each brand, the Salty Cat review covers its cat range, the Bella + Duke review covers its raw formats, and the PETstock review covers its dry and freeze dried lines. PETstock has been trading since 2002, a useful signal of how established a supply brand is before you hand over your card details.
Delivery decides whether you stay
Salty Cat runs a subscription, and so do Bella + Duke (subscription) and PETstock, so the differences that matter are timing, geography and how easily you can stop. Salty Cat ships in the United States and offers support by email and help centre. Bella + Duke covers GB, NL and BE from GB, offers email, phone and chat, and lets you pause or cancel online.
Dispatch time is the number to pin down. PETstock publishes a dispatch window of 2 to 3 days. Bella + Duke’s raw food travels frozen, which adds handling steps that a dry or canned format does not have, and a frozen format needs freezer space plus a plan for the week a box arrives late. Both subscription brands offer a personalised plan, and a personalised first order is a good way to test portion sizes before you commit to a routine delivery rhythm.
Judge reliability by who answers
Reliability is hard to read off a product page, so use the practical signals. Bella + Duke trades as Bella & Duke Ltd, keeps its headquarters in the United Kingdom and answers through email, phone and chat. Salty Cat offers support by email and help centre alone, which is worth knowing before you order a large first box and something needs sorting out.
Reachability matters more than badges. A brand that answers a question about a specific recipe before you subscribe has already told you how a problem gets handled when a delivery is late, a cat rejects a flavour or a pack arrives damaged. Formulation credentials such as a vet nutritionist or a named nutritionist are the other part of that picture, because they explain who set the recipe numbers you checked earlier.
A short order of operations
Run the checks in this order: the format your cat will eat, the life stage, entry price and per day cost, protein variety and the nutrition standard, then dispatch timing and how easy it is to cancel. Compare in a different order and a large intro discount tends to sit at the top of the list while a format your cat refuses sits at the bottom.
Once the shortlist is down, widen it with the cat food brand rankings and set other options such as Natures Menu, Animonda and Health Extension beside the three above, so your final choice rests on more than a single company.