In short
Whether a brand makes food for dogs, for cats, or for both.
Species tells you which animals a brand actually makes food for. A dog-only range narrows the choice, while a brand covering both species lets one household order from a single maker. A Pup Above makes food for dog alone. AATU Dog and Cat Food and ACANA both cover dog and cat, and alpha spirit Hunde- und Katzenfutter and Animonda also serve dog and cat. If you keep a dog and a cat, the shared brands simplify both shopping lists.