Updated 17 October 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team

KitNipBox vs PetSmart Canada

KitNipBox logo

KitNipBox

9.3

Pick KitNipBox for more markets (2 against 1).

PetSmart Canada logo

PetSmart Canada

9.6

Pick PetSmart Canada for a loyalty scheme.

See the category

Key differences

  • PetSmart Canada scores higher overall: 9.6 against 9.3.
  • Only PetSmart Canada has a loyalty scheme.
  • Among support channels, only KitNipBox offers Email.
  • KitNipBox is available in 1 more country.
  • KitNipBox has more markets (2 against 1).

Side by side

KitNipBox vs PetSmart Canada
KitNipBox logoKitNipBoxPetSmart Canada logoPetSmart Canada
Cost
Free delivery threshold$0CA$49
Shipping fee$0in the lowest quarter of 28 brandsNot listed
Offer
Pet pharmacyNoYes
Vet serviceNoYes
Loyalty schemeNoYes
Third-party sellersNoNot listed
MarketsCanada, United StatesCanada
Delivery and service
Repeat-order discountNot listed35%in the highest quarter of 30 brands
Same-day deliveryNoYes
Dispatch time2 days2 to 3 days
Money-back periodNot listed60 daysin the highest quarter of 63 brands
Company
Legal entityKitNip Brands, Inc.PetSmart LLC
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited States
Support channelsEmail, Phone, Help centrePhone, Help centre

Our verdict on each

KitNipBox

KitNipBox is a cat treat subscription for owners who want the delivery charge removed and the box skippable between cycles, with a grain free option in the mix. It carries an overall score of 9.3 in the comparison data, and the delivery money is what pulls that score up.

Read the full KitNipBox review

PetSmart Canada

PetSmart Canada suits Canadian pet owners buying food, supplies and pharmacy items in the same basket, and it rewards the ones who reorder on a schedule. Scheduled reorders save 35% each time, orders over CAD 49 ship free, and delivery stops at CA.

Read the full PetSmart Canada review

Pros and cons

KitNipBox

Pros

  • Delivery carries no extra cost: the shipping fee is $0 and the free delivery threshold is $0, so the delivery cost does not change with the size of the order.
  • A grain free option is available, which fits a cat already on a grain free diet.
  • Pausing and cancelling are both handled online, so a cycle can be skipped without a phone call.

Cons

  • The range is cat only, cat, so there is nothing here for a dog household.
  • Speed sits in the middle: dispatch is 2 days and same day delivery is not offered, so the box suits a routine rather than a quick top up.
  • There is no pharmacy and no vet service, so medicines and vet advice have to be arranged elsewhere.

PetSmart Canada

Pros

  • Pharmacy and a vet service sit on the same site, so health items and veterinary care come in the same order flow.
  • Same day ordering covers urgent top-ups, while standard orders still go out in 2 to 3 days.
  • The money back window of 60 days leaves room to try a new food and send it back if the pet turns its nose up.

Cons

  • The CAD 49 free delivery threshold is high enough that a small top-up order still pays delivery.
  • Support runs on phone and help centre only, so there is no live chat or email route for questions.
  • Coverage is limited to CA, so this store does not serve shoppers in any other market.

Who each suits

KitNipBox

Who it suits

  • Cat owners who treat feeding as a routine and would rather not reorder each month.
  • Shoppers who would rather not clear a basket minimum to get delivery.
  • Owners feeding a grain free diet who want the subscription to handle it.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Dog households: the range is cat only, cat, so Petbarn is the listed alternative to check for a dog basket.
  • Same day shoppers: same day delivery is not offered and dispatch is 2 days, so PETstock is the alternative to compare when speed is the priority.
  • Owners who need medicines or vet advice: there is no pharmacy and no vet service here, and PetSmart Canada is the listed alternative to compare on a wider pet shop basket.

PetSmart Canada

Who it suits

  • Canadian owners who reorder the same food and supplies each month and want the discount applied without remembering a code.
  • Shoppers who want a pharmacy and a vet service inside the same account as their everyday pet shopping.
  • Households whose basket usually clears CAD 49, taking delivery off the bill.

Who should look elsewhere

  • PETstock, if reaching free delivery at AUD 25 matters more than having a pharmacy and vet service in the same account.
  • Petbarn, if you are not shopping in Canada, since that store works in a different market and currency.

Questions about each

KitNipBox

How much does a KitNipBox subscription cost?

KitNipBox lists a plan price rather than a discounted opening rate paired with a separate renewal rate, and the subscription starts at $25.99. Delivery does not add to it: the shipping fee is $0 and the free delivery threshold is $0, so the entry figure is the figure that lands on the invoice.

Does KitNipBox charge for delivery?

Delivery is $0 and the free delivery threshold is $0, so there is no basket minimum to clear before delivery is free. Boxes go out on a subscription with dispatch in 2 days, and same day delivery is not offered, so the timing is planned rather than urgent.

PetSmart Canada

How much do I save by putting an order on autoship?

Autoship takes 35% off every reorder placed on the schedule, which makes it the biggest lever on what you pay over time. There is no separate trial rate to remember: the discount attaches to each scheduled delivery, so the saving repeats for as long as the order stays on autoship.

Is there a loyalty programme as well as autoship?

The store runs a loyalty programme, and it works alongside autoship rather than replacing it. The autoship discount of 35% applies to scheduled reorders, while loyalty rewards sit on everyday purchases, so a shopper who reorders and also drops into the site occasionally picks up saving on both routes.

Sources

KitNipBox

  • kitnipbox.com: 12 facts, checked 30 September 2026

PetSmart Canada

  • petsmart.ca: 12 facts, checked 30 September 2026