Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team

Health Extension vs Natures Menu

Health Extension logo

Health Extension

No. 4 of 138 in dog food brands9.4

Best for: One recurring brand covering both dogs and cats across every format.

Natures Menu logo

Natures Menu

No. 35 of 138 in dog food brands9.4

Best for: UK pet owners who want every format from a single subscription and will use the 10% intro discount on the opening box.

See the category

Key differences

  • Among food types, only Health Extension offers Fresh cooked and Air dried.
  • Among food types, only Natures Menu offers Raw.
  • Among proteins, only Health Extension offers Buffalo.
  • Among proteins, only Natures Menu offers Beef, Turkey and Pork.
  • Among life stages, only Health Extension offers All.

Side by side

Health Extension vs Natures Menu
Health Extension logoHealth ExtensionNatures Menu logoNatures Menu
Cost and Offer
Price from$2.99£2.29
SpeciesDog, CatDog, Cat
Food typesFresh cooked, Freeze dried, Air dried, Dry, Wet, TreatsRaw, Wet, Dry, Freeze dried, Treats
Personalised recipeNoYes
Introductory discount35%Higherabove the median of 106 brands10%below the median of 106 brands
RecipesNot listed160in the highest quarter of 104 brands
ProteinsChicken, Lamb, Salmon, Duck, Venison, BuffaloBeef, Chicken, Turkey, Duck, Lamb, Salmon
+ 6 morePork, Venison, Rabbit, Tripe, Fish, Goose
Grain-free optionYesYes
Life stagesPuppy, Adult, Senior, AllPuppy, Adult, Senior
Human-grade claimYesNo
Trust
Nutrition standardComplete AAFCOComplete fediaf
Formulated byVet nutritionistVet nutritionist
Other facts
Energy per 100 g367.8 kcalsabove the median of 81 brands163 kcalsbelow the median of 81 brands
Protein24%at the median of 113 brands13%in the lowest quarter of 113 brands
Fat18%in the highest quarter of 111 brands11%below the median of 111 brands
MarketsUnited StatesUnited Kingdom
Delivery and service
Delivery modelSubscriptionSubscription
Pause or cancel onlineYesYes
Frozen shippingNoYes
Company
Legal entityNot listedNatures Menu Limited
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited Kingdom
Founded1963Not listed
Support channelsEmail, Chat, Phone, Help centrePhone, Chat, Email, Help centre

Our verdict on each

Health Extension

Health Extension suits owners of dogs and cats who want one brand across fresh-cooked, dry, air-dried, freeze-dried, wet and treats, with an introductory offer of 35% on a recurring order. Recipes are not personalised and the catalogue sells in the US only, so a single supplier covers the household rather than a tailored plan.

Read the full Health Extension review

Natures Menu

Natures Menu suits UK pet owners who want a single subscription covering every format it lists, from raw, wet and dry for dog and cat. Entry pricing starts at £2.29, the first order takes 10% off, and 160 recipes make a switch easy, with raw boxes shipped frozen.

Read the full Natures Menu review

If neither fits

How they place

Raw and freeze-dried dog food
Health Extension 3 of 52 by score · Natures Menu 12 of 52 by score
Cat food brands and delivery
Health Extension 3 of 110 by score · Natures Menu 21 of 110 by score
Dog treats
Health Extension 7 of 145 by score · Natures Menu 30 of 145 by score

Pros and cons

Health Extension

Pros

  • One brand covers dog and cat with a format spread running to fresh cooked, freeze dried and air dried, so a dog and a cat can be fed from the same account.
  • An introductory offer of 35% applies to the first recurring order, which takes the sting out of a subscription arrangement.

Cons

  • Frozen shipping: no, so the fresh-cooked and air-dried formats in fresh cooked, freeze dried and air dried arrive without chilled handling.
  • It sells in US only, so a household outside that market gets no delivery from this catalogue.

Natures Menu

Pros

  • A £2.29 starting point with 10% off the first order makes the opening box cheaper than the headline figure.
  • A single account covers raw, wet and dry and puppy, adult and senior, so a household with a puppy and a cat can order from the same subscription.
  • Food is formulated by a vet nutritionist to the complete fediaf standard, with a grain free option for dogs that need one.

Cons

  • Coverage is GB only, so the range cannot reach buyers outside the UK, and the intro offer does not change that limit.
  • The intro discount of 10% is a smaller cut than the 10% to 35% band most dog food brands sit in.
  • Natures Menu makes no human grade claim, so buyers who treat that wording as a quality marker on packaging need to look elsewhere.

Who each suits

Health Extension

Who it suits

  • Owners of both dogs and cats who want one supplier across fresh cooked, freeze dried and air dried rather than separate shops.
  • Shoppers inside US who can use a subscription order, take the 35% introductory offer and pause or cancel online.
  • Households feeding across life stages, since puppy, adult and senior are all covered by the range.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Anyone outside the US, since US lists a single market and Ollie, PetPlate or tails.com are the names to compare for local coverage.
  • Owners who want a recipe matched to their own dog, because Personalised: no applies here and Ollie or PetPlate are the alternatives worth checking first.

Natures Menu

Who it suits

  • Owners in the UK feeding raw alongside raw, wet and dry who want a single subscription that covers puppy, adult and senior and both species on one account.
  • Raw feeders who want frozen delivery and a complete fediaf complete diet formulated by a vet nutritionist rather than a generic label.
  • Shoppers who want to pause or cancel online between deliveries, backed by phone, chat and email when a box needs changing.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Buyers outside GB, where Natures Menu does not ship, and Ollie is dog only, so no listed option widens the reach.
  • Single dog households wanting a simpler basket, since PetPlate is dog only and does not ask for the dog and cat range or the full raw, wet and dry spread.

Questions about each

Health Extension

What does Health Extension food cost?

Food starts at $2.99, priced in USD, and that entry price ranks 44 of 152 brands compared. A typical recipe lists protein at 24% and fat at 18%, with energy at 367.8 kcal per 100 g. The introductory offer of 35% comes on top once the order repeats.

Is there a new customer discount, and how does the recurring order work?

Recurring orders run on subscription, and new customers see an introductory offer of 35%. That is above the 20% most brands on the site run, and it ranks 26 of 103 on this measure. The order repeats unless the customer changes it.

Natures Menu

What does Natures Menu cost to start a subscription?

Entry pricing begins at £2.29, and the first order takes 10% off. That is a starting point rather than a typical basket, so the real cost depends on recipe, pack size and how often a box is delivered. Orders run on subscription delivery, which is how the range is sold.

Does the introductory discount carry on at renewal?

The 10% reduction applies at the start, and the subscription then continues on the standard rate for later deliveries. Across the site, introductory discounts cluster around 10% to 35%, so this one sits at the modest end. Check the recurring amount on the order summary before confirming.

Sources

Health Extension

  • healthextension.com: 21 facts, checked 30 September 2026

Natures Menu

  • naturesmenu.co.uk: 22 facts, checked 30 September 2026