Updated 30 September 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team

Evermore Pet Food vs Ollie

Evermore Pet Food logo

Evermore Pet Food

No. 10 of 138 in dog food brands8.8

Best for: US dog and cat owners wanting fresh-cooked and freeze-dried food on a single subscription.

Ollie logo

Ollie

No. 23 of 138 in dog food brands9.7

Best for: Dog owners wanting personalised fresh-cooked meals on a subscription with a strong entry discount.

See the category

Key differences

  • Ollie scores higher overall: 9.7 against 8.8.
  • Ollie has a lower entry price ($1 against $12.50).
  • Among support channels, only Ollie offers Chat.
  • Among species, only Evermore Pet Food offers Cat.
  • Among food types, only Evermore Pet Food offers Freeze dried and Treats.

Side by side

Evermore Pet Food vs Ollie
Evermore Pet Food logoEvermore Pet FoodOllie logoOllie
Cost and Offer
Price from$12.50above the median of 77 brands$1Lowerin the lowest quarter of 77 brands
SpeciesDog, CatDog
Food typesFresh cooked, Freeze dried, TreatsFresh cooked, Dry
Personalised recipeNoYes
Introductory discountNot listed50%in the highest quarter of 106 brands
Recipes4in the lowest quarter of 104 brands5Higher
ProteinsBeef, Chicken, Turkey, LambBeef, Chicken, Turkey, Lamb, Pork
Grain-free optionYesNot listed
Life stagesAdultNot listed
Human-grade claimYesYes
Trust
Nutrition standardComplete AAFCONot listed
Formulated byVet nutritionistVet nutritionist
Delivery and service
Delivery modelSubscriptionSubscription
Frozen shippingYesNot listed
Other facts
Energy per 100 g123.46 kcalsin the lowest quarter of 81 brandsNot listed
Protein12%in the lowest quarter of 113 brandsNot listed
Fat7%in the lowest quarter of 111 brandsNot listed
MarketsUnited StatesNot listed
Delivery and service
Pause or cancel onlineYesNot listed
Company
Legal entityEvermore Pet Food, Inc.Not listed
HeadquartersUnited StatesNot listed
Founded2009Not listed
Support channelsEmail, Phone, Help centreEmail, Phone, Chat, Help centre

Our verdict on each

Evermore Pet Food

Evermore Pet Food suits US owners of dogs and cats who want fresh-cooked, freeze-dried and treat choices under a single subscription. Entry at $12.50 and an overall 8.8 place it well against PetPlate and Ollie, though 4 recipes and adult life stages keep the plan narrow.

Read the full Evermore Pet Food review

Ollie

Ollie suits dog owners who want fresh-cooked meals built around their own dog and a first order that costs little. The starting price is $1 with an entry discount of 50%, and the range holds 5 recipes. Personalisation is the reason to look past the short recipe list.

Read the full Ollie review

If neither fits

How they place

Fresh dog food delivery
Evermore Pet Food 4 of 34 by score · Ollie 6 of 34 by score

Pros and cons

Evermore Pet Food

Pros

  • Fresh-cooked, freeze-dried and treats all sit under a single subscription, listed as fresh cooked, freeze dried and treats.
  • Recipes are formulated by a vet nutritionist and the range is sold to complete AAFCO.
  • Pausing or cancelling online is available, and support runs on email, phone and help centre between boxes.

Cons

  • The Personalised fact reads no, so a dog cannot be moved onto a portion or ingredient plan made for a single animal.
  • Adult is the only life stage listed, so puppies and senior dogs fall outside the stated range.
  • Orders ship frozen, which suits a freezer at home but adds cold chain handling, and US is the only market covered.

Ollie

Pros

  • Personalised nutrition is offered as standard, and the wider dog food category treats it as a minority feature.
  • Recipes cover beef, chicken and turkey, so there is some choice of protein across the list.
  • Human grade claim is made, and support runs on email, phone and chat when a box goes wrong.

Cons

  • Recipe count is 5, a shorter list than many fresh-cooked ranges carry, with beef, chicken and turkey across it.
  • Food types listed are fresh cooked and dry, so a wet or treat option is not among the range.
  • Personalisation narrows the choice, since each dog gets a recipe built around it rather than picking from a full menu, with 5 recipes behind it.

Who each suits

Evermore Pet Food

Who it suits

  • US dog and cat households feeding fresh-cooked or freeze-dried food on a subscription, since dog and cat covers both species.
  • Adult dogs on a short list, since 4 recipes across beef, chicken and turkey is easy to track and reorder.
  • Owners who want a stated standard, with complete AAFCO and formulation by a vet nutritionist.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Ollie, for anyone who wants meals tailored to a single dog, because the Personalised fact here reads no.
  • PetPlate, for a household that wants to skip frozen delivery, because Evermore ships frozen and lists US only.
  • tails.com, for puppy and senior feeding, because adult covers adult dogs only.

Ollie

Who it suits

  • Dog owners who want fresh-cooked food matched to their own dog rather than picking from a fixed menu each time the box arrives.
  • Pet owners who read price at entry closely and like a large first order discount before the renewal price.
  • People who want phone, chat and email help alongside a help centre when a delivery goes wrong.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Bella + Duke, which covers dog and cat if you want a brand for more than one pet.
  • tails.com, which lists dry, wet and treats if you want treats or wet food in the same order.
  • PetPlate, which lists fresh cooked, dry and wet for anyone feeding a dog and a cat from one brand.

Questions about each

Evermore Pet Food

What does Evermore Pet Food cost?

The starting figure is $12.50, and the range is bought on a subscription rather than as single boxes. On entry price that puts Evermore Pet Food at position 114 of the 152 brands ranked here, which is the figure to weigh before delivery and recipe choices.

Is Evermore Pet Food personalised?

No, the Personalised fact reads no. Every dog eats from the same set of 4 recipes built on beef, chicken and turkey, so nothing is adjusted for a single animal’s weight, age or allergy. Owners who want a portion or ingredient plan shaped per dog would need a brand built around that, or a vet working on top of these recipes.

Ollie

How much does Ollie cost to start?

The starting price is $1, and the first order carries an introductory discount of 50%. Delivery runs on a subscription, so the discount applies to the opening order rather than to every delivery that follows.

Does the discount last, or does the price rise at renewal?

The introductory offer is 50% and it is tied to the opening order. Because the food arrives on a subscription, later boxes are billed at the standard plan price, so budget the standard price as your ongoing cost rather than the discounted one.