Updated 14 October 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
Top brands in the United States compared
Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.
- 301
Not ratedSubscription- Delivery model
- Subscription
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Mixed dog and cat households, since dog and cat covers both under a single plan.
- Owners who want formulation by a vet nutritionist rather than a general nutritionist.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat households already settled on Ollie or PetPlate, since dog and dog are dog only.
Read review- Personalised recipe
- Yes
- Recipes
- 32
- Formulated by
- Vet nutritionist
- 302

Hill's
Top pickBest for: Owners who want a familiar brand in the aisle and a choice of recipes for dogs and cats.
Not ratedRetail- Delivery model
- Retail
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog and cat owners who want one familiar brand for both pets
- Shoppers who prefer buying food in person to a recurring delivery
Look elsewhere if
- Dog only buyers looking for a different range, since Ollie covers dog and PetPlate the same
- Shoppers who want a pausable subscription, as the model is retail and tails.com covers dog
Read review- Recalls
- 2019-01-31: Hill's Prescription dog food and wet Science Diet - Elevated levels of vitamin D, 2014-06-02: Science Diet Adult Small and Toy Breed dry dog food - potential salmonella contamination, 2007-03-16: Science Diet Savory Cuts canned cat food - melamine contamination
- Legal entity
- Hill's Pet Nutrition, Inc.
- Headquarters
- United States
- Founded
- 1907
- 303
Jollyes
Top pickBest for: UK pet owners browsing supplies across common household and small-animal categories.
Not ratedNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
- 304
Kölle Zoo
Top pickBest for: A single order covering dog and cat food, treats and raw, bought retail rather than on a plan.
Not ratedNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog and cat owners who want food, treats and raw ordered together instead of from separate shops.
- Shoppers after a grain free option who care more about catalogue breadth than a personalised diet.
Look elsewhere if
- People who want a subscription with a locked renewal price, as retail is retail.
Read review- Support channels
- Help centre
- 305

Natural Balance
Top pickBest for: Shelf buyers who want a grain free option with named limited ingredient proteins.
Not ratedRetail- Delivery model
- Retail
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners of a dog with a sensitive stomach who has done better on a limited ingredient recipe built around salmon, duck and bison.
- Households that prefer to pick a bag up in a shop, since buying runs through retail channels.
Look elsewhere if
- Puppy and senior households who need a stated life stage. The named recipe is built for adult dogs, and tails.com spans dog food from pup to senior.
Read review- Proteins
- Salmon, Duck, Bison
- Energy per 100 g
- 336 kcals
- Protein
- 24%
- 306

Nulo
Top pickBest for: Grain free dog and cat food bought as a retail bag in US, CA and IT, not a subscription.
Not ratedRetail- Delivery model
- Retail
- Grain-free option
- Yes
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners who want dry, wet and treats choices with a grain free option under the same brand.
- People whose dog moves through puppy, adult and senior and who want one nutrition standard across those stages.
Look elsewhere if
- Owners who want a set recurring box: retail keeps this a bag at a time and pause cancel online is not available, so repeat ordering stays manual.
Read review- Personalised recipe
- No
- Proteins
- Turkey, Salmon, Trout
- Energy per 100 g
- 361.4 kcals
- 307
Orivet
Top pickBest for: Readers who keep dogs and cats and want breed and health reporting from a single provider.
Not ratedNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Households with a dog and a cat at home, since Orivet tests dog and cat under the same provider.
Look elsewhere if
- Dog-only households that will never test a cat, since DNA My Dog's breed test covers dog and suits a narrower need.
Read review- Breed test price
- $94.99
- Breed and health test price
- $158.95
- Sample method
- Swab
- 308
Not ratedNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners who want a breed read and are content to study the report without a vet in the loop.
- Households that want a written corporate operator behind the swab, since the test runs under Neogen Corporation.
Look elsewhere if
- Cat owners, because species covers dog only, where Wisdom Panel covers dog and cat.
- Multi-pet households that prefer one supplier, since EasyDNA and Basepaws both list dog and cat.
Read review- Legal entity
- Neogen Corporation
- Support channels
- Email, Phone
- 309

PEDIGREE
Top pickBest for: Dog owners who want a familiar dry and wet range they can pick up in a shop rather than have delivered.
Not ratedRetail- Delivery model
- Retail
- Grain-free option
- No
- Nutrition standard
- Complete AAFCO
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Dog owners feeding a dog through every stage in puppy, adult and senior without changing brand.
- Shoppers who want dry, wet and treats in a single brand and would rather leave the shop with the food than wait for a box.
Look elsewhere if
- Ollie buyers who want fresh cooked, since Ollie's range is fresh cooked and dry and Pedigree does not list that format.
- PetPlate shoppers who want fresh cooked alongside wet and treats, which PetPlate covers with fresh cooked, dry and wet.
Read review- Personalised recipe
- No
- Recipes
- 14
- Proteins
- Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and 1 more
- 310
Petdirect
Top pickBest for: Owners who buy food, treats and equipment together and restock on a schedule.
Not ratedNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Read reviewFits you if
- Multi-pet households that value a wide shelf over fast, urgent delivery.
- 311
PetFlow
Top pickBest for: Everyday food, treats and pharmacy health items on a repeat schedule, with a phone route into support.
Not ratedNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Pet owners ordering the same food and treats on a repeat schedule who would rather pick up the phone than chase the largest discount.
- Shoppers who want pharmacy health items in the same basket as food rather than managing a second supplier.
Look elsewhere if
- Not for buyers chasing the deepest autoship discount, since PetSmart Canada lists 35% against PetFlow's 10%.
- Not for shoppers who want a mid-range repeat saving, since PETstock lists 15% on autoship.
Read review- Repeat-order discount
- 10%
- Pet pharmacy
- Yes
- Support channels
- Email, Chat, Phone
- 312
Pets at Home
Top pickBest for: Owners in GB who want repeat food and supply orders plus a veterinary service from the same company.
Not ratedNot listed- Delivery model
- Not listed
- Grain-free option
- Not listed
- Nutrition standard
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Owners in GB who want veterinary care and repeat food and supply ordering handled by the same company.
- Regular buyers who would rather hold a dependable 10% saving than chase the largest promotion going.
Look elsewhere if
- PetSmart Canada buyers, whose auto-ship discount of 35% leaves the 10% on repeat orders here well behind.
- PETstock shoppers, who can put 15% on autoship orders instead of 10% on repeat orders at the same purchase size.
Read review- Repeat-order discount
- 10%
- Vet service
- Yes
- Loyalty scheme
- Yes
- Markets
- United Kingdom
- Legal entity
- Pets at Home Ltd