Updated 17 November 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team

Top dog treats compared

145 brands, ranked on the terms we checked.

Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.

What matters most
BrandScorePrice fromDelivery modelPersonalisedPersonalised recipe Read moreIntroductoryIntroductory discount Read moreRecipesProteinsGrain-free option
  • 73

    JustFoodForDogs

    Top pick

    Best for: Frozen, vet nutritionist formulated food for US dogs and cats, with a strong joining discount and online cancellation.

    9.0
    $9.99
    Subscription
    Yes
    50%
    15
    Chicken, Beef, Fish +3
    Not listed
    Price from
    $9.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    Yes
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • US dog and cat households happy with a single market and a subscription rhythm (dog and cat, US, subscription).
    • Owners feeding puppies or adult dogs who want complete food from a vet nutritionist.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Cat-first households, since Ollie and tails.com list dogs only.
    • Owners outside US, where PetPlace covers a single market and Ollie is the comparison worth making first.
    Introductory discount
    50%
    Recipes
    15
    Proteins
    Chicken, Beef, Fish, and 3 more
    Read review
  • 74

    Lilys Kitchen

    Top pick

    Best for: One subscription covering dog and cat food, from fresh-cooked through to treats.

    9.0
    £3.70
    Subscription
    No
    20%
    Not listed
    Chicken, Salmon, Pork
    Yes
    Price from
    £3.70
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    No
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Dog and cat households that prefer a single supplier, since Lilys Kitchen covers dog and cat while Ollie lists dog.
    • Owners who want a complete food to complete fediaf, with every recipe set by vet nutritionist.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Buyers who need a personalised recipe, since Lilys Kitchen offers no personalised plans. Ollie is listed among the alternatives here.
    • Pet owners set on frozen food or shopping on a human grade label, since Lilys Kitchen has neither frozen shipping nor a human grade claim. PetPlate is listed among the alternatives.
    Introductory discount
    20%
    Proteins
    Chicken, Salmon, Pork
    Grain-free option
    Yes
    Read review
  • 75

    Milk-Bone

    Top pick

    Best for: Everyday biscuit treats for puppy and adult dogs, bought when the cupboard runs low.

    9.0
    Not listed
    Retail
    No
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Peanut butter, Chicken +2
    No
    Price from
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Retail
    Personalised recipe
    No
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who would rather pick up a bag as needed than manage a delivery plan, because the model is retail
    • Households already feeding a full ration from a brand listing fresh cooked, dry and wet, who just want a biscuit treat on the side

    Look elsewhere if

    • Cat households: Salty Cat is built around cat food, while Milk-Bone covers dog only
    • Anyone after fresh-cooked meals on a repeating delivery, since PetPlate lists fresh cooked, dry and wet against Milk-Bone's treats
    Proteins
    Peanut butter, Chicken, Beef, and 1 more
    Grain-free option
    No
    Nutrition standard
    Complementary
    Energy per 100 g
    315 kcals
    Read review
  • 76

    Nom Nom

    Top pick

    Best for: Personalized fresh-cooked meals with a vet nutritionist behind the recipe sheet.

    9.0
    $9.99
    Subscription
    Yes
    25%
    8
    Turkey, Beef, Chicken +2
    Not listed
    Price from
    $9.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    Yes
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Dog owners in the US who want their dog's portion worked out for them and a fresh-cooked range formulated by a vet nutritionist.
    • Readers who want complete AAFCO meals and treats from one supplier rather than a separate order for each.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Readers who prefer food that sits on a shelf, since tails.com lists dry, wet and treats with no fresh-cooked meals to thaw.
    • Buyers who want dry food alongside fresh-cooked, since Ollie lists fresh cooked and dry where the Nom Nom range stops at fresh cooked and treats.
    Introductory discount
    25%
    Recipes
    8
    Proteins
    Turkey, Beef, Chicken, and 2 more
    Read review
  • 77

    Open Farm

    Top pick

    Best for: Households that want dog and cat food, several formats and online subscription control from one Canadian brand.

    9.0
    $9.99
    Subscription
    Yes
    25%
    Not listed
    Beef, Chicken, Turkey +8
    Yes
    Price from
    $9.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    Yes
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Dog owners who want several formats, fresh cooked, raw and freeze dried, from one subscription
    • Cat households that want a single supplier covering dog and cat

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers who want a one off purchase instead of a subscription, since delivery is subscription only
    • Anyone outside US and CA who needs home delivery
    Introductory discount
    25%
    Proteins
    Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and 8 more
    Grain-free option
    Yes
    Read review
  • 78

    Raw Paws Pet Food

    Top pick

    Best for: US owners wanting raw, freeze-dried, dry and treats on one autoship plan.

    9.0
    $7.99
    Subscription
    Yes
    15%
    19
    Beef, Chicken, Duck +7
    Not listed
    Price from
    $7.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    Yes
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • US owners feeding raw who also want freeze-dried, dry and treats covered in the same place
    • Households that prefer an autoship plan they can pause or cancel from the account

    Look elsewhere if

    • Cat-first households, since Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com list dog, dog and dog only, against dog and cat here
    • Buyers who want one complete ration on its own, since the recipes are labelled complementary
    Introductory discount
    15%
    Recipes
    19
    Proteins
    Beef, Chicken, Duck, and 7 more
    • Cost8.9
    • Offer9.3
    • Trust8.6
    Read review
  • 79

    Steve's Real Food

    Top pick

    Best for: Adult dogs and cats fed raw or freeze-dried food in the US, bought through stockists.

    9.0
    Not listed
    Retail
    No
    Not listed
    6
    Beef, Chicken, Pork +3
    Yes
    Price from
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Retail
    Personalised recipe
    No
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Adult dog and cat owners in the US who already shop retail for raw or freeze-dried food
    • Multi-pet households wanting raw, freeze-dried and treats from one brand, given dog and cat and raw, freeze dried and treats

    Look elsewhere if

    • Ollie, if personalisation is the deciding factor
    • PetPlate, if you want portions tuned to a single dog
    Recipes
    6
    Proteins
    Beef, Chicken, Pork, and 3 more
    Grain-free option
    Yes
    Nutrition standard
    Complete AAFCO
    Read review
  • 80

    Tales & Tails

    Top pick

    Best for: A low cost dog or cat food subscription for households in Germany and nearby European markets.

    9.0
    €2.49
    Subscription
    No
    15%
    33
    Lamb, Fish, Horse +3
    Not listed
    Price from
    €2.49
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    No
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Dog and cat owners in the EU and Switzerland who want one subscription for the whole household
    • Families that want a grain free option without paying fresh food prices

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone in the UK, since the shipping markets do not cover it
    • Pet owners who need feeding matched to their dog's individual needs, which Ollie handles as a personalised service
    Introductory discount
    15%
    Recipes
    33
    Proteins
    Lamb, Fish, Horse, and 3 more
    • Cost9.5
    • Offer9.0
    • Trust8.2
    Read review
  • 81

    Tuggs

    Top pick

    Best for: Personalized fresh-cooked dog food in GB and IM, delivered on a subscription you can pause or cancel online.

    9.0
    £3.99
    Subscription
    Yes
    Not listed
    5
    Turkey, Beef, Chicken +3
    Not listed
    Price from
    £3.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    Yes
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Dog owners in GB and IM who want fresh-cooked food brought to the door rather than collected.
    • Owners who want a grain free option and a human grade claim on the same plan.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Owners who want dry or wet food in the same order: tails.com lists dry, wet and treats, while Tuggs sells fresh cooked and treats.
    • Buyers who want the widest format choice in one brand: PetPlate covers fresh cooked, dry and wet, a broader shelf than Tuggs offers.
    Price per day
    £1
    Recipes
    5
    Proteins
    Turkey, Beef, Chicken, and 3 more
    • Cost9.1
    • Offer9.3
    • Trust8.0
    Read review
  • 82

    Annie'sPoochPops

    Top pick

    Best for: Cheap repeat treat subscriptions for dogs in the US.

    8.9
    $5.99
    Subscription
    No
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Peanut butter, Cheese +5
    Yes
    Price from
    $5.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    No
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Dog owners in the US who want chews and training treats delivered on repeat, not a full meal.
    • Shoppers looking for a grain free option and a human grade claim in a treat box.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Cat owners, since Salty Cat is built around cat.
    • Owners who want a full cooked meal rather than treats, because PetPlate covers fresh cooked, dry and wet.
    Proteins
    Peanut butter, Cheese, Bacon, and 4 more
    Grain-free option
    Yes
    Human-grade claim
    Yes
    • Cost9.1
    • Offer8.8
    • Trust8.8
    Read review
  • 83

    BIXBI Pet

    Top pick

    Best for: US dog and cat owners wanting shelf-stable and freeze-dried food on a subscription.

    8.9
    $3.99
    Subscription
    No
    5%
    Not listed
    Beef, Chicken, Duck +6
    Yes
    Price from
    $3.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    No
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Owners of dogs and cats in the US who want dry, wet and freeze-dried options in one place
    • People who prefer a grain free option

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone outside the US, since BIXBI Pet serves US only
    • Buyers who want personalised recipes, which Ollie offers for dog
    Introductory discount
    5%
    Proteins
    Beef, Chicken, Duck, and 6 more
    Grain-free option
    Yes
    • Cost9.2
    • Offer8.7
    • Trust8.9
    Read review
  • 84

    Brutus Broth

    Top pick

    Best for: A plain subscription box of wet and treats food for adult pets in US and CA.

    8.9
    $6.99
    Subscription
    No
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Beef, Chicken, Pork +1
    Not listed
    Price from
    $6.99
    Not listed
    Delivery model
    Subscription
    Personalised recipe
    No
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Owners in US and CA feeding an adult dog or a cat, since dog and cat pets are covered and Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com each list dog.
    • Readers who want to hold a plan from the account, since pause and cancel are online and support runs on email, phone and help centre.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Readers who want a dog-only brand: Ollie, PetPlate and tails.com each list dog only, while Brutus Broth covers dog and cat.
    • Puppy and senior households: adult covers adult pets, and the subscription box is the only buying route, so a reader feeding across life stages needs more than one plan.
    Proteins
    Beef, Chicken, Pork, and 1 more
    Formulated by
    Not stated
    Human-grade claim
    Yes
    • Cost9.0
    • Offer9.1
    • Trust8.5
    Read review
The price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read moreWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read moreCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more

About this ranking

This ranking covers the brands in our dog treat comparison, drawn from a pool of 166 tracked brands. Every member sells a treat line, so that is the starting filter. After it, the order weighs what a subscriber pays when a plan starts and what the plan costs once the introductory offer has run out. Those figures hide what most buyers notice first: the introductory offer, which reaches 70% at the top of the range and 2% at the bottom. A plan can look cheap because of the discount rather than the list price. Reach is the second trade-off. A brand that ships to a single market answers a narrower audience than one covering much of Europe. The third is what sits in the treat aisle beside the treats: dry, wet, fresh-cooked, raw, freeze-dried and air-dried lines carry different storage and delivery conditions, and some arrive frozen. Read every price here as an entry point, not a promise.

How we picked

Ranking scores use weighted factors, and the weights are published. Cost and offer together decide most of the order, which is why a deep introductory discount can lift a plan with a middling list price. Trust then separates brands that look close on money. Facts come from each brand's own pages. The pricing and subscription page gives the entry price, the introductory offer, and whether a plan can be paused or cancelled online. Delivery pages give market coverage, food types and frozen shipping. Recipe pages give the nutrition standard, the proteins used and life stages. Contact pages give support channels. Where a brand states a standard or a claim, it is kept as written rather than read into. Treats decide eligibility. Brands that sell a treat line alongside fresh-cooked, dry, wet, raw, freeze-dried or air-dried food enter the list. A cat-only brand stays on it, but it carries a lower species weight than a dog-led range. Where scores sit close, the tie breaks on the plan detail a subscriber feels at renewal.

How we rank

What to look for

Entry price against the field
A plan's starting price means little alone. Prices under the midpoint leave room in the basket later.
Introductory offer and the price after it
An introductory offer lowers the opening order and not much else. Offers here run from 2% to 70%, and the midpoint offer is 20%. Check the entry price before judging any deal.
Cost per day
A per day figure is easier to hold in the head than a basket total.
What the treat line sits next to
Treats carry the heaviest weight in this category, 100%, so a brand that treats them as an afterthought scores below one built around them. Formats beside the treats count too: dry sits at 57% and fresh-cooked at 20%.
Species and life stages
A brand covering a single life stage is a narrower answer.
Support and easy exits
Pausing or cancelling online is the common case here, 75%. Reach matters next: email sits at 85% and phone at 63%, so a brand limited to a help centre is harder to reach.

Questions

Which brand has the deepest introductory offer?

That discount applies to the plan you open with.

Which plan is cheapest to start?

Starting prices here are quoted in pounds, dollars and euros, so read each against the currency on your own bill. Some brands publish a price per day, which is the fairer test for a fresh food or treat plan. Check whether you can pause or cancel online before you subscribe.

Can I pause or cancel a plan online?

Every brand in this ranking lets you pause or cancel a subscription online, without a call. The depth of support differs: Bella + Duke runs on email, phone and chat and Health Extension on email, chat and phone, while Animonda is limited to help centre. Formatted help pages are common, and a live chat line appears at some brands.

Which of these carries treats in more formats?

Health Extension and Tackenberg carry the broadest spreads, listing fresh cooked, freeze dried and air dried and raw, wet and dry. Wider spreads let treats share a delivery with the rest of the diet.

Are any of these made for cats rather than dogs?

Several brands serve dogs and cats, including Bella + Duke, Tackenberg, Animonda and Health Extension, whose species cover reads dog and cat. The rest of the list is dog-led.

How much does delivery add on?

Brands that ship frozen add a cold chain, which shapes how often a treat-only order can travel.

Keep comparing