Updated 21 October 2026 · KibbleCue Editorial Team
BestVetCare vs PupJoy
BestVetCare
No. 3 of 149 in online pet stores8.9Pick BestVetCare for a loyalty scheme and more markets (15 against 1).

PupJoy
No. 13 of 149 in online pet stores8.9Pick PupJoy for a longer money-back period (30 days against 7 days).
Key differences
- PupJoy has a longer money-back period (30 days against 7 days).
- Only BestVetCare has a loyalty scheme.
- Among support channels, only BestVetCare offers Chat, Phone and Help centre.
- BestVetCare is available in 14 more countries.
- BestVetCare has more markets (15 against 1).
Side by side
PupJoy | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Free delivery threshold | $49 | $49 |
| Shipping fee | $9.95in the highest quarter of 28 brands | Not listed |
| Offer | ||
| Pet pharmacy | Yes | No |
| Vet service | Not listed | No |
| Loyalty scheme | Yes | No |
| Third-party sellers | Not listed | No |
| Markets | Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Israel+ 9 moreItaly, Japan, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Portugal, Slovakia, Sweden, Switzerland, United States | United States |
| Delivery and service | ||
| Repeat-order discount | 5%in the lowest quarter of 30 brands | 10% to 30%Higherabove the median of 30 brands |
| Same-day delivery | Yes | No |
| Money-back period | 7 daysin the lowest quarter of 63 brands | 30 daysat the median of 63 brands |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Hjp Trading Ltd | PupJoy LLC |
| Headquarters | Cyprus | United States |
| Support channels | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre | |
| Pet food | ||
| Delivery model | Retail | Subscription |
| Price from | $8.29 | $6.99Lower |
| Frozen shipping | No | No |
| Pet food | ||
| Species | Dog, Cat | Dog |
| Food types | Not listed | Treats |
| Personalised recipe | Not listed | Yes |
| Introductory discount | Not listed | 30% |
| Recipes | Not listed | 6 |
| Proteins | Not listed | Duck, Beef, Chicken |
| Nutrition standard | Not listed | Complementary |
| Life stages | Not listed | All |
| Energy per 100 g | Not listed | 413 kcals |
| Protein | Not listed | 38% |
| Fat | Not listed | 30% |
| Formulated by | Not stated | Not stated |
| Human-grade claim | No | No |
| Pause or cancel online | Yes | Yes |
Our verdict on each
BestVetCare
BestVetCare suits dog and cat owners who want pet food, a pharmacy and everyday supplies bought together in a retail basket rather than a subscription. Entry prices start at $8.29, delivery turns free at $49, and same day ordering is available.
Read the full BestVetCare reviewPupJoy
PupJoy is a US treats subscription for dog owners who want a repeat box rather than a full pet store basket. Autoship cuts 10% to 30% and a 30 days money back window softens the commitment, though the food is complementary and there is no pharmacy or vet service.
Read the full PupJoy reviewIf neither fits
Pros and cons
BestVetCare
Pros
- Same day delivery is available, and dispatch adds 0 days, so an early order can still land the same day.
- A pharmacy sits alongside food, and every order carries a money back window of 7 days.
- Autoship orders can be paused and cancelled online, and loyalty points add rewards on repeat buys.
Cons
- There is no frozen shipping, so chilled or frozen diets have to be bought elsewhere.
- There is no human grade claim on the food, so shoppers who look for that wording need to read the labels.
PupJoy
Pros
- Autoship takes 10% to 30% off repeat orders, and a plan can be paused or cancelled online without a call.
- Treats start at $6.99, so a first box is a small outlay before you commit to a schedule.
- An introductory discount of 30% applies on top of the autoship saving, so the entry price and the renewal price differ.
Cons
- The treats are sold as complementary food, so they work beside a full diet rather than replacing one.
- Support runs on email only, so a delivery or refund question is answered in writing.
- PupJoy has no pharmacy and no vet service, so medication and clinical advice sit outside the offer.
Who each suits
BestVetCare
Who it suits
- Dog and cat owners buying food, pharmacy items and everyday supplies in a single retail basket.
- Loyalty point users who reorder the same food and want to pause or cancel repeat orders online.
Who should look elsewhere
- Small top-up orders that would rather have free delivery sooner: Happy and Polly’s threshold is $19.
PupJoy
Who it suits
- US dog owners who buy the same treats every few weeks and want repeat orders to cost less.
- Households that want portions matched to one dog, since personalised plans are offered and the range is dog only.
- Anyone feeding treats to a puppy, adult or senior dog, since the treats cover all life stages.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers outside the US: PupJoy’s market is US, while Petbarn and PETstock are set up for Australian delivery.
- PetSmart Canada buyers, since PupJoy does not ship to Canada and its range is treats only.
- Anyone after a small basket delivered free, since PETstock’s AUD 25 threshold is lower than PupJoy’s $49.
Current offers
BestVetCare
Bonus
Welcome reward points on registration: 100 reward points (worth $5)
New customers who register on bestvetcare.com; redeemable on orders of $25 or more, up to 10% of order value; points expire after 10 months
Source, checked 30 September 2026
PupJoy
First period offer
Save 30% on first BYO subscription order
Save 30% on first order and 10% on every shipment after that
Source, checked 30 September 2026
Questions about each
BestVetCare
How much is delivery, and when is it free?
Shipping is $9.95 for orders, and delivery is free once a basket reaches $49. That bar is low enough that a routine food and pharmacy shop clears it without a large order. Single-item top-ups are the orders that end up paying the fee, so filling the basket first is the cheapest way to avoid it.
What does a first order start at?
Entry pricing starts at $8.29. The store sells as a retail basket, so there is no plan tier to choose: the total depends on what a household stocks, and food, pharmacy items and everyday supplies all count towards the same $49 free delivery limit.
PupJoy
How much do PupJoy treats cost?
PupJoy’s treats start at $6.99. A first order carries an introductory discount of 30%, while repeat orders on autoship come off 10% to 30%. The published duck sausage with bone broth is 38% protein and 30% fat, with 413 kcal per 100 g of energy listed for it, so a treat can be weighed by calories as well as by pack.
What does autoship save me?
PupJoy’s delivery model is subscription, so boxes arrive on a repeat cycle rather than as single purchases. Repeat orders are cut by 10% to 30%, and a plan can be paused or cancelled online. The saving only applies while a subscription is running, so occasional treat buyers pay the standard price on every order.
Sources
BestVetCare
- bestvetcare.com: 12 facts, checked 30 September 2026
PupJoy
- pupjoy.com: 12 facts, checked 30 September 2026




